Japan makes major step toward revising controversial retrial system

Japan has taken a major step toward revising the country's retrial system, which has been criticized as making the process of overturning a wrongful conviction excessively lengthy.

But the prospects of swift reform are unclear, with fierce opposition from within the Justice Ministry to one of the key proposed changes -- restricting objections from prosecutors against court decisions ordering retrials.

On March 28, the Legislative Council, a ministry advisory body, was asked by Justice Minister Keisuke Suzuki to look into the issue.

"The public's interest (in the issue) is extremely high. I expect to receive recommendations as early as possible," Suzuki told a press conference earlier in the day.

The move followed the highly publicized acquittal last year of 89-year-old Iwao Hakamada, who had spent nearly half a century on death row following a quadruple murder conviction.

"It's not just a matter of saving Iwao," said his sister Hideko Hakamada, 92, as she attended a gathering in the Diet several days earlier to seek the revision of a system that has been left untouched since the criminal procedure law was established in 1948.

It took 42 years after first applying for a retrial to reopen her brother's high-profile 1966 murder case.

In the decades-long struggle for justice by the former boxer and his family, they faced what seemed an insuperable hurdle in prosecutors' reluctance to disclose evidence and their objections to reopening the case.

The criminal procedure law stipulates that a retrial will be opened if there is "clear evidence to find the accused not guilty." But it lacks provisions on the disclosure of evidence held by prosecutors, hindering efforts to overturn convictions, experts say.

Iwao Hakamada is not the only one who had to wait for decades until new evidence opened the door for a retrial.

Shoshi Maekawa, 59, filed a request for a retrial in 2004 after serving a seven-year sentence for the 1986 murder of a junior high school girl in central Japan.

The Nagoya High Court's Kanazawa branch decided in 2011 to reopen the case, but the decision was overturned by the Nagoya High Court following an objection from prosecutors.

After filing a second request for a retrial in 2022, the Kanazawa court ordered a retrial as 287 new pieces of evidence disclosed by prosecutors undermined the credibility of the testimonies from Maekawa's acquaintances that led to his conviction.

He is almost certain to be acquitted after his retrial was held in March.

The Japan Federation of Bar Associations has criticized the current system for allowing prosecutors to file objections against court decisions to reopen a case, which often result in the rulings being overturned.

"It has been a major factor delaying relief for the victims facing false accusations," said the group, which has been supporting many seeking retrials.

That issue, along with rules on evidence disclosure for deciding on retrials, are the main topics of the council's discussions.

"It is true that there are problems. The ministry will lose trust if we do nothing," said a senior ministry official.

But some legal and prosecution officials are strongly against restricting prosecutors from appealing. Another senior ministry official, for instance, cited a 1979 murder case in which a 97-year-old woman was convicted.

Ayako Haraguchi served 10 years in prison for killing her brother-in-law in Kagoshima Prefecture in 1979. In her third request for a retrial, the Supreme Court decided against reopening the case although district and high courts had ruled in her favor.

"Even courts have diverging views. We should still leave room for three rounds of deliberations," the official said.

Under the usual process of legal revisions, the council would recommend the outline for revisions following discussions. The ministry would then prepare a bill and submit it to parliament for deliberation.

The process only requires a month if the path toward revisions is clear from the beginning, but it is likely to take more than one year if there are many points of disagreements, with one official expecting discussions to take at least a year.

Meanwhile, a group of over 370 cross-party lawmakers is working with the Japan Federation of Bar Associations to amend the system through legislation drafted by Diet members during the current session.

Masahiko Shibayama, the leader of the lawmakers' group, said revisions needing urgent responses can be made through lawmaker-drafted legislation with remaining issues left for examination by the ministry panel.

Its outline of a bill to revise the criminal procedure law includes obliging courts to order prosecutors to disclose evidence if requested by lawyers acting for those seeking retrials as well as banning objections from prosecutors against reopening cases.

"Parliament is the highest organ of state power. It is clear that our process should be prioritized (over the ministry's move) under the Constitution," Shibayama said.

Source: Japan Today, Staff, April 14, 2025

"One is absolutely sickened, not by the crimes that the wicked have committed,
but by the punishments that the good have inflicted."

— Oscar Wilde

Comments

Boston Marathon bomber’s appeal of death sentence marked by delays and secrecy

As the city marks the 12th anniversary of the Boston Marathon bombings, Dzhokhar Tsarnaev sits on federal death row for admittingly detonating bombs at the finish line that killed three people and injured more than 260 others. Yet, his fate remains uncertain after a decade of legal wrangling, as his lawyers continue to challenge his death sentence. The federal judge who presided over his 2015 trial was ordered by an appeals court in March 2024 to investigate defense claims that two jurors were biased and should have been stricken from the panel. If he finds they were, then Tsarnaev is entitled to a new trial over whether he should be sentenced to life in prison or death, according to the appeals court.

Singapore executes man for 2017 murder of pregnant wife and daughter

Teo Ghim Heng, who strangled his pregnant wife and four-year-old daughter in 2017 before burning their bodies, was executed on 16 April 2025 after exhausting all legal avenues. His clemency pleas were rejected and his conviction upheld by the Court of Appeal in 2022. Teo Ghim Heng, who was convicted of murdering his pregnant wife and their four-year-old daughter in 2017, was executed on 16 April 2025. The Singapore Prison Service confirmed that Teo’s death sentence was carried out at Changi Prison Complex. In a news release on the same day, the police stated: “He was accorded full due process under the law, and was represented by legal counsel both at the trial and at the appeal. His petitions to the President for clemency were unsuccessful.”

USA | They were on federal death row. Now they may go to a supermax prison.

A group of federal prisoners filed a lawsuit this week accusing the Trump administration of seeking to move them to a supermax prison to face tougher conditions as punishment for having their death sentences commuted by President Joe Biden. President Donald Trump has repeatedly criticized Biden’s decision to commute the sentences of 37 federal death row inmates to life in prison without parole. After his inauguration, Trump ordered that the former death row prisoners be housed “in conditions consistent with the monstrosity of their crimes and the threats they pose.”

USA | Who are the death row executioners? Disgraced doctors, suspended nurses and drunk drivers

These are just the US executioners we know. But they are a chilling indication of the executioners we don’t know Being an executioner is not the sort of job that gets posted in a local wanted ad. Kids don’t dream about being an executioner when they grow up, and people don’t go to school for it. So how does one become a death row executioner in the US, and who are the people doing it? This was the question I couldn’t help but ask when I began a book project on lethal injection back in 2018. I’m a death penalty researcher, and I was trying to figure out why states are so breathtakingly bad at a procedure that we use on cats and dogs every day. Part of the riddle was who is performing these executions.

Indonesia | British grandmother who has spent 12 years on death row hugs grandchildren for first time as they visit Bali prison

Lindsay Sandiford, 68, reportedly shared 'cuddles and kisses' with her loved ones for the first time in years A British grandmother who has been stuck on death row in Bali for more than a decade has been reunited with her loved ones for the first time in years. Lindsay Sandiford has been locked up in Indonesia's notorious Kerobokan Prison since 2013 after being found guilty of trying to smuggle £1.6million of cocaine into the country.

Indiana Supreme Court sets May 20 execution date for death row inmate Benjamin Ritchie

The condemned man has exhausted his appeals but is likely to seek a clemency plea. Indiana Supreme Court justices on Tuesday set a May 20 execution date for death row inmate Benjamin Ritchie, who was convicted in 2002 for killing a law enforcement officer from Beech Grove. The high court’s decision followed a series of exhausted appeals previously filed by Ritchie and his legal team. The inmate’s request for post-conviction relief was denied in Tuesday’s 13-page order, penned by Chief Justice Loretta Rush, although she disagreed with the decision in her opinion.

Louisiana to seek death penalty for child killer despite Biden’s commutation

CATAHOULA PARISH, La. — While a federal death row sentence has been reclassified by former President Joe Biden to life without parole, the State of Louisiana still seeks the death penalty for a man convicted of the kidnapping, torturing and murdering a child in Catahoula Parish. According to a statement by the Seventh Judicial District of Louisiana District Attorney Bradley Burget, on Monday, a Catahoula Parish Grand Jury indicted Thomas Steven Sanders for the first-degree murder of 12-year-old Lexis Kaye Roberts in 2010.

Texas executes Moises Mendoza

Moises Sandoval Mendoza receives lethal injection in Huntsville for death of 20-year-old Rachelle O’Neil Tolleson A Texas man convicted of fatally strangling and stabbing a young mother more than 20 years ago was executed on Wednesday evening. Moises Sandoval Mendoza received a lethal injection at the state penitentiary in Huntsville and was pronounced dead at 6.40pm, authorities said. He was condemned for the March 2004 killing of 20-year-old Rachelle O’Neil Tolleson.

Afghanistan | Four men publicly executed by Taliban with relatives of victims shooting them 'six or seven times' at sport stadium

Four men have been publicly executed by the Taliban, with relatives of their victims shooting them several times in front of spectators at a sport stadium. Two men were shot around six to seven times by a male relative of the victims in front of spectators in Qala-i-Naw, the centre of Afghanistan's Badghis province, witnesses told an AFP journalist in the city. The men had been 'sentenced to retaliatory punishment' for shooting other men, after their cases were 'examined very precisely and repeatedly', the statement said. 'The families of the victims were offered amnesty and peace but they refused.'

In Alabama, a Volunteer to Die

James Osgood has been executed by the State of Alabama. Read an eyewitness account. There were no protestors today on the side of Highway 21 in Atmore, Alabama, outside Holman Correctional Facility where the state would soon begin its execution of James Osgood. Instead, under a cloudy spring sky, a few guard trucks were parked at the prison’s first gate, lonely in the grassy plains. Before, at the state’s previous killings, protestors have often flanked the roadside nearest those trucks, their dissenting bodies one of the few signals in the landscape of the death about to occur inside the prison’s gates.

Death Penalty News

Search This Blog