Ruben Gutierrez Set to Be Executed; Texas denies his request for DNA testing

It looks very likely that the state of Texas will execute Ruben Gutierrez on July 16 without ever having DNA tested fingernail scrapings, bloodstains, and hair that he says will prove he is not a murderer.

Gutierrez was convicted in 1999 of conspiring with two other men to rob Escolastica Harrison, the operator of a Brownsville trailer park. The state’s evidence showed that two of the three men entered Harrison’s mobile home and killed her as they searched for hidden cash. Gutierrez has long asserted that he stayed outside the home and had no idea the others were planning to murder Harrison. His attorneys have argued there is no forensic evidence connecting him to the murder and that he was convicted on the strength of a false confession he offered when police threatened to jail his wife and have his kids placed in foster care.

For the last 13 years, Gutierrez has been trying to get some court, any court, to order the DNA testing to help prove he wasn’t in the room when Harrison was killed. The request was first denied in 2011 by the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, the same court that recently approved Gov. Greg Abbott’s pardon of convicted murderer Daniel Perry. The CCA ruled that since Gutierrez had been convicted under Texas’ controversial “law of parties” statute – which specifies that anyone involved in a crime can be held accountable for other crimes committed during its commission – it didn’t really matter whether he’d entered the trailer. In other words, he could still be executed even if he hadn’t harmed, or meant to harm, Harrison, so why allow the testing?

Gutierrez continued fighting for the testing, however, and in 2019 he and his attorney, Shawn Nolan, challenged the constitutionality of the Texas laws governing when DNA from settled cases can be tested. Nolan describes these laws as one of the classic Catch-22’s of the death penalty.

“One statute says that you can file an appeal that you should not have received the death penalty,” Nolan said. “And then the other statute says you can only get DNA testing if you can prove you’re innocent. Well, how do you prove you’re innocent before you get the testing? It’s a Catch-22 that violates due process and the Constitution.”

“[One] statute says you can only get DNA testing if you can prove you’re innocent. Well, how do you prove you’re innocent before you get the testing? It’s a Catch-22.”– Attorney Shawn Nolan

Nolan has appealed the case to the United States Supreme Court and thinks it’s possible the justices will take it. Meanwhile, he continues to wonder why the state of Texas would go on sending its attorneys to oppose DNA testing if they’re confident Gutierrez’s verdict is correct.

“There’s no question that if this case happened today, everything would be tested,” Nolan said. “So our position has always been, what are they so afraid of? It’s certainly not the cost – we’ve offered to pay for it.”

SBS

Meanwhile, the Innocence Project is gearing up to save the life of Robert Roberson, now that Texas has set Roberson’s execution for Oct. 17. According to the Innocence Project, which is representing Roberson, if the execution goes forward he will be the first person in the country to be put to death on the basis of “shaken baby syndrome,” a concept that is now under scrutiny.

Since 1992, at least 32 parents and caregivers in 18 states have been exonerated after being convicted under the shaken baby hypothesis, according to the National Registry of Exonerations.

Roberson was convicted of murdering his 2-year-old daughter Nikki in 2003. Nikki had battled a high fever and undiagnosed pneumonia in the week before her death. Roberson said she died after a fall from her crib.

Roberson’s case has echoes of those of Rosa Jimenez and Melissa Lucio, who are also represented by Innocence Project attorneys. Like Roberson, Jimenez and Lucio were convicted of murdering toddlers after scientists presented testimony at their trials that was later found to be misleading. Jimenez was exonerated and released last August after 20 years behind bars. A judge overseeing Lucio’s trial court recommended in April that her conviction be overturned. She is currently waiting for the CCA, the same court that has refused DNA testing to Gutierrez, to sign off on the request.

Source: austinchronicle.com, Brant Bingamon, July 12, 2024

_____________________________________________________________________

Twitter/X | Facebook | Telegram | Contact Us

"One is absolutely sickened, not by the crimes that the wicked have committed,
but by the punishments that the good have inflicted."

— Oscar Wilde

Florida Set to Execute Man Who Said He Killed to Reach Death Row, Challenging Misconception that Death Penalty Deters Crime

Florida is scheduled to execute James Robertson at noon on Tuesday, October 13, at Florida State Prison. His execution remains scheduled despite the withdrawal of William Lee Thompson’s death warrant, which had called for a 2nd execution that evening. If completed, this will be Florida’s 17th execution of 2026. Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty (FADP) and partners will be holding a series of vigils and demonstrations across the state.

Christa Pike's Survival Wasn't a Miracle. That's What Should Scare Us.

What happened in Tennessee's execution chamber is one of the most common failures in medicine Christa Pike is awake. A week after Tennessee strapped her to a gurney and gave her two doses of pentobarbital , she is off the ventilator and speaking from a hospital bed, still shackled to it. Her lawyers call her recovery " medically unprecedented. " Legal scholars say she is the first person in American history to survive a lethal injection after the drug was actually given. I understand the impulse to make such claims. I consulted for Pike's legal team, but I have also spent three decades in operating rooms and intensive care units (ICUs), and I want to resist the word "unprecedented" and the word "miracle" that hovers just behind it.

Tennessee | Republicans legislature to investigate other execution methods after failed lethal injections

Republican leaders in Tennessee’s legislature say they will investigate the reliability of lethal injection as an execution method after the state failed to execute two death row inmates in the span of five months. Gov. Bill Lee stopped the May execution of Tony Carruthers after a physician unsuccessfully attempted to insert intravenous lines to begin the lethal injection process for over an hour. Death row inmate Christa Pike survived two failed rounds of Tennessee’s lethal injection protocol on Sept. 30 before the execution was halted. Pike, who was sentenced to death for the 1995 murder of Colleen Slemmer, is receiving medical care in a Nashville hospital.

Christa Pike: 4 Major Questions As She Returns to Death Row

As Christa Pike returns to death row after surviving Tennessee’s attempt to execute her, several questions remain about her case and what comes next. Pike, 50, was discharged from hospital and moved back to the Debra K. Johnson Rehabilitation Center, the women’s prison where she was housed for 30 years, her attorneys said on Saturday. She was hospitalized after surviving 2 doses of the lethal drug pentobarbital as Tennessee attempted to execute her on September 30. Pike was sentenced to death for the 1995 murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer, her classmate at a Job Corps training program in Knoxville, Tennessee. Pike was 18 at the time.

What Tennessee wants to do next to Christa Pike is beyond grim

Christa Pike, the woman who survived two execution attempts in Tennessee earlier this week, remains hospitalized in critical condition, where presumably medical staff is at work trying to keep her alive. If she wakes from the coma she had entered, Tennessee officials want to start anew to inject lethal drugs into her seemingly too-small veins to kill her and carry out the state death warrant. Pike also is being treated for “significant injuries to both arms” sustained when two lethal injections of pentobarbital failed to kill her. If she dies, there will be no need to try again. As we know by now, Tennessee tried to put Pike to death Wednesday night by lethal injection for a murder she committed when she was 18. She would have been the first woman executed in the state in 200 years.

Florida executes James Robertson

STARKE, Fla. — A Florida prisoner who said he killed his cellmate specifically to get on death row was executed Tuesday, nearly 18 years after the attack. James Robertson, 63, declined to offer any last words before receiving a three-drug injection and was pronounced dead about 10 minutes later. It was a stark contrast to the failed execution of Christa Pike in Tennessee two weeks ago, where she was rushed to the hospital after surviving two lethal doses of pentobarbital.

USA | Firing squad execution to be livestreamed, Pentagon says

The public will be able to watch the execution of a former US Army major by firing squad, US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth has said. A Defense Department official told the BBC the execution of Nidal Hasan, who shot dead 13 unarmed US soldiers at Fort Hood in 2009, would be livestreamed. It is believed it would be the first public execution in the US in almost a century. The decision to livestream it is "unprecedented in the modern era" and "on uncertain legal terrain", said John Mills, a lawyer who works with inmates sentenced to death.

Tennessee | Christa Pike’s lawyer says she has not regained consciousness since her failed execution

Christa Pike has remained unconscious and on a ventilator at a hospital in the four days since her failed execution in Tennessee, and her prognosis might not be known for days more, one of her lawyers said Sunday. Little has been released about Pike’s condition since Wednesday night’s execution attempt. She has since remained hospitalized under guard as doctors try to get the massive dose of the barbiturate pentobarbital out of her system. When asked whether she ever regained consciousness after the execution attempt, Assistant Federal Defender Stephen Ferrell, Pike’s lawyer, said on CNN’s “State of the Union”: “Not that I am aware of.”

Opinion | I Know Christa Pike’s Medical History. What Tennessee Did Is Unforgivable.

Dr. Zivot is an anesthesiologist and intensive care physician. He consulted on Christa Pike’s case before her attempted execution. On Wednesday night, Christa Pike lay strapped to a gurney at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution in Nashville while the State of Tennessee injected pentobarbital, a sedative that is lethal in high doses, into her veins. When the 1st dose did not kill her, the execution team gave her a 2nd. At one point, she told the room her arm felt as if it were about to burst. She was nearly correct. More than an hour after the procedure began, an ambulance was called. She was severely injured but still alive.

After Christa Pike survives lethal injection, America's shameful botched executions

The US is one of the few Western nations that still permits the death penalty, carried out regularly in 27 states. And in a country where regional political culture strongly favours retributive justice, it is no wonder capital punishment remains an enduring part of the American legal system. But following Christa Pike's botched lethal injection last week, fresh questions are being raised over whether executing convicted murderers and rapists outweighs the risks of an innocent person being put to death, or of an execution going so badly that a prisoner is left to die in agony, or even survives the attempt.

Death Penalty News

Search This Blog