Pope Declares Death Penalty Inadmissible in All Cases

ROME — Pope Francis has declared the death penalty inadmissible in all cases because it is “an attack” on the “dignity of the person,” the Vatican announced on Thursday, in a definitive shift in Roman Catholic teaching that could put enormous pressure on lawmakers and politicians around the world.
Francis, who has spoken out against capital punishment before — including in 2015 in an address to Congress — added the change to the Catechism, the collection of beliefs for the world’s 1.2 billion Catholics.
The revision says the church would work “with determination” for the abolition of capital punishment worldwide.
“I think this will be a big deal for the future of the death penalty in the world,” said John Thavis, a Vatican expert and author. “People who work with prisoners on death row will be thrilled, and I think this will become a banner social justice issue for the church,” he added.
Sergio D’Elia, the secretary of Hands Off Cain, an association that works to abolish capital puni…

California justice calls for new rules on eyewitness identification in court

A California Supreme Court justice, dissenting Monday in a death penalty decision, called for new rules to curb inaccurate eyewitness identification, a leading cause of wrongful convictions.

The dissent came in a case in which the court decided 5 to 2 to uphold the death sentence of Ennis Reed, convicted of killing 2 people in Compton.

Justice Goodwin Liu wrote the dissent, calling on the courts to better police eyewitness testimony. Justice Leondra Kruger did not sign Liu's dissent but wrote separately, saying she was dissenting in Reed's case for the reasons Liu cited.

Reed was sentenced to death in 1999 for killing Amarilis Vasquez and Paul Moreland in separate incidents.

Evidence at Reed's death penalty trial showed he had dropped out of school after 7th grade, when he was performing at the level of a 3rd- or 4th-grader, and had been convicted in 1992 of attempted murder for driving a car in which a passenger shot someone from the vehicle.

In the appeal of his death penalty case, Reed, who is African American, argued that the prosecutor discriminated against African Americans in picking the jury and that the evidence, largely testimony by eyewitnesses, did not support the convictions.

Reed also challenged the eyewitness testimony. In the case of one of the witnesses, Reed was the only bald person in a 6-photo array and the only person to appear in both the photos and the in-person lineup.

Justice Mariano-Florentino Cuellar, writing the majority ruling, rejected Reed's claims. Cuellar cited a variety of reasons that justified the prosecutor's decision to exclude some African Americans while keeping others.

The court majority also said the eyewitness identification was buttressed by evidence that placed Reed near the scene of one of the killings and with an individual whose last name matched someone police chased that night into a home that contained the murder weapon.

Moreover, the majority said, an eyewitness in 1 of the killings identified Reed in 2 lineups and at the preliminary hearing.

Liu, joined by Kruger, said the conviction had to be overturned because the trial judge failed in his legal responsibility to examine the prosecutor's motives after Reed's lawyer objected to the removal of several African American prospective jurors.

"As a result of the trial court's error, we cannot be confident that Reed was convicted by a jury selected without regard to race," Liu wrote.

The dissent also stressed that the law was not keeping pace with the science on eyewitness identification.

The eyewitnesses in Reed's case saw the assailant while they were under great stress, in poor lighting and at a distance, the dissent said. They also were a different race from the perpetrator, and 1 of them did not identify Reed in a photo lineup until several months after the killing.

Citing an array of research, Liu said new jury instructions should be written to help jurors understand the problematic nature of eyewitness testimony and weigh its accuracy.

Law enforcement also can reduce the risk of inaccuracy, Liu wrote, by videotaping lineups and ensuring the operator of the lineup does not know which person is the suspect.

"But there is little that courts can do to induce law enforcement to adopt these practices unless courts themselves subject such evidence to greater scrutiny," Liu said.

He said the state high courts of Oregon and New Jersey have taken steps to try and ensure that trial judges better police eyewitness testimony and called on the Legislature and the Judicial Council, the policymaking body for the courts, to address the issue.

"This case provides another example of the problematic nature of eyewitness identification evidence, particularly where such evidence is the sole or principal evidence against the defendant," Liu wrote.

Source: Los Angeles Times, Maura Dolan, May 7, 2018

⚑ | Report an error, an omission, a typo; suggest a story or a new angle to an existing story; submit a piece, a comment; recommend a resource; contact the webmaster, contact us: deathpenaltynews@gmail.com.

Opposed to Capital Punishment? Help us keep this blog up and running! DONATE!

"One is absolutely sickened, not by the crimes that the wicked have committed,
but by the punishments that the good have inflicted." -- Oscar Wilde

Most Viewed (Last 7 Days)

New Study: Death Penalty Costing Nebraska Taxpayers $14.6 Million Each Year

The Brits on death row around the world hoping to escape execution

Nebraska executes Carey Dean Moore

Should 'Late Adolescence' Protect Young People from Execution?

Paralysis, eye gouging, amputation, crucifixion: The Medieval punishments faced by criminals in Saudi Arabia

USA: State of Nebraska set to carry out first execution in 21 years

Fentanyl Used to Execute Nebraska Inmate, in a First for U.S.

75 Catholic priests and scholars ask Francis to backtrack on death penalty

URGENT APPEAL for Anthony Haynes to be executed in Texas on 18 October

How Carey Dean Moore's execution, Nebraska's 1st lethal injection, will be carried out