Texas: With a man's execution days away, his victims react with fury or forgiveness

For the past 3 months, Christopher Anthony Young has awoken in his 10-by-6 foot concrete cell on death row and had to remind himself: He's scheduled to die soon.
As the day crept closer, the thought became more constant for Young, who's sentenced to die for killing Hasmukh "Hash" Patel in 2004.
"What will it feel like to lay on the gurney?" he asks himself. "To feel the needle pierce my vein?"
Mitesh Patel, who was 22 when Young murdered his father, has anxiously anticipated those moments, as well. He wonders how he will feel when he files into the room adjacent to the death chamber and sees Young just feet away through a glass wall.
For years, Patel felt a deep hatred for Young. He wanted to see him die. Patel knew it wouldn't bring his father back. But it was part of the process that started 14 years ago when Young, then 21, gunned down Hash Patel during a robbery at Patel's convenience store on the Southeast Side of San Antonio.
3 mont…

Roof's mental status uncertain; his attorneys seek delay to Charleston death penalty trial

Dylann Roof
Dylann Roof
The current mental status of accused Charleston church killer Dylann Roof has emerged as a key issue and may delay the start of his upcoming death penalty trial.

Legal papers on the U.S. District Court internet site made public Friday make it clear that defense and prosecution lawyers are wrangling over the issue of Roof's mental competency. They are also fighting over whether a final hearing on Roof's mental status - now scheduled for Wednesday in Charleston - will be open or closed.

After that hearing, U.S. Judge Richard Gergel will likely issue an order saying whether Roof is mentally fit to stand trial, or whether he should be hospitalized until he is competent.

Under the law, a defendant must be able to understand the nature of the proceedings against him and assist his lawyers in his own defense. Roof, 22, is an avowed white supremacist from the Columbia area. He faces 33 charges including hate crimes in connection with the June 2015 Charleston church massacre, in which 9 African-Americans were killed execution-style. His lawyers have said in open court he will plead guilty and be sentenced to life without parole in prison if prosecutors drop their demand for the death penalty.

According to a defendant's filing in the case made public Friday, U.S. Judge Richard Gergel has already made a finding "that there is reasonable cause to believe that the defendant may presently be suffering from a mental disease or defect rendering him mentally incompetent to stand trial..."

Although the defense motion does not say when Gergel made that finding, the judge apparently did so after a closed hearing Monday at which the public and prosecutors were excluded. At that hearing, Roof's defense lawyers presented evidence indicating he was not mentally stable.

As prescribed by law when questions of a defendant's mental competence arise, Gergel then appointed an independent mental health professional to examine Roof. That examination is now apparently finished, or near finished, and the results will be given to Gergel.

The results of that examination will likely play a large role in Wednesday's upcoming hearing and may determine if Roof's trial can go on as scheduled.

"If, after the hearing, the court finds by a preponderance of the evidence that the defendant is presently suffering from a mental disease or defect rendering him mentally incompetent to the extent that he is unable to understand the nature and consequences of the proceedings against him...," the defendant shall be hospitalized, federal law law says.

That hospitalization shall continue until the defendant's mental condition improves to the point where he can stand trial, federal law says.

Defense lawyers are seeking to close Wednesday's hearing about Roof's mental status, according to a filing unsealed Friday.

"Any (open) competency hearing will pose equally grave threats to the defendant's right to a fair trial, to a fair and impartial jury, and to the assistance of counsel," defense lawyers wrote.

However, prosecution lawyers argue in a strongly-worded brief that, for numerous reasons, the Wednesday hearing about Roof's competency should be open to the public and victims.

"The victims should not be held in the dark about the competency hearing," the government argued. "The victims in this case have a right to know what is occurring in this case."

"While the defendant does have a right to a fair trial, so too do the victims have a right to a fair trial, one that affords them access to the information and proceedings that address their experience and loss as well as the person who caused it," the government argued.

Government lawyers also reminded Gergel that U.S. courts are traditionally open and there is "a strong presumption of open proceedings."

Moreover, since the public already knows that Roof's mental competence is an issue, "there is no sufficiently compelling interest in closing the hearing," prosecutors wrote.

Roof's mental status is currently being evaluated in a confidential setting. Judge Gergel is expected to get a report on Roof's competence soon.

"Should the defendant be found incompetent, we presume that the Court would order him transferred to a Bureau medical facility for further evaluation and treatment aimed at restoring him to competence," defense lawyers wrote.

Defense lawyers also indicate they want to delay jury selection now for perhaps an indefinite time, as the matters concerning Roof's competency are legally complex and will likely take a long time to deal with in a manner that will protect Roof's rights.

"With a holiday coming up, we wish to avoid having to make any more last-minute requests for time to resolve the numerous issues of constitutional dimension that seem to be arising now virtually on a daily basis," wrote Roof's defense team, headed by noted anti-death penalty lawyer David Bruck.

"We suggest that the Court adopt a new schedule that avoids resuming jury selection on Nov. 21-22," Bruck and his team wrote.

Gergel announced earlier this week he wanted to start jury selection on Nov. 21, the Monday the week of Thanksgiving.

Gergel had originally planned to start jury selection last Monday, but to everyone's surprise, Roof's lawyers asked for and got a closed court hearing at which last-minute mental competency issues concerning Roof arose. Neither prosecutors nor the public were allowed to attend that hearing.

Source: thestate.com, November 12, 2016

⚑ | Report an error, an omission; suggest a story or a new angle to an existing story; send a submission; recommend a resource; contact the webmaster, contact us: deathpenaltynews@gmail.com.

Opposed to Capital Punishment? Help us keep this blog up and running! DONATE!

Most Viewed (Last 7 Days)

Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles rejects clemency for Chris Young

20 Minutes to Death: Record of the Last Execution in France

Alabama: 8 death row inmates request execution by nitrogen gas

Scott Dozier case: Hours before execution, judge in pharma company suit halts use of drug

Utah to seek death penalty for parents charged with killing daughter, covering her in makeup

Indonesia: Gay couple publicly whipped after vigilante mob drags them out of beauty salon

Fentanyl And The Death Penalty

Sale of guillotine divides France

Chinese court sentences man to death over school stabbings

The Aum Shinrikyo Executions: Why Now?