Innocent on Death Row? New Evidence Casts Doubt on Convictions

Rodney Reed’s death sentence was suspended. But researchers say other current cases raise similar doubt about the guilt of the accused.
The number of executions in the United States remains close to nearly a three-decade low. And yet the decline has not prevented what those who closely track the death penalty see as a disturbing trend: a significant number of cases in which prisoners are being put to death, or whose execution dates are near, despite questions about their guilt.
Rodney Reed, who came within days of execution in Texas before an appeals court suspended his death sentence on Friday, has been the most high-profile recent example, receiving support from Texas lawmakers of both parties and celebrities like Rihanna and Kim Kardashian West, who urged a new examination of the evidence.
Mr. Reed has long maintained that he did not commit the 1996 murder for which he was convicted. And in recent months, new witnesses came forward pointing toward another possible suspect: the dead…

Texas: Prosecutor in Anthony Graves case disbarred

Anthony Graves (center) with his son (right) and brother (left) holds a letter
by the State Bar of Texas Office of the Chief Disciplinary Counsel.
The former district attorney who successfully prosecuted Anthony Graves for capital murder, sending Graves to prison for 18 years for a crime he did not commit, has been disbarred, according to state bar officials.

Former Burleson County District Attorney Charles Sebesta Jr. lost his law license after an administrative hearing into Graves' case.

Graves was freed from prison four years ago after serving more than 18 years for the 1992 murder of six Burleson County residents. On two occasions, he was scheduled to be executed.

In a ruling issued Thursday, the disciplinary panel found that Sebesta failed to provide several items of exculpatory evidence to the defense during Graves' trial, presented false testimony to the jury, made a false statement of material fact to the trial judge and engaged in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit or misrepresentation.

"Mr. Sebesta's disbarment cannot begin to make up for what happened to Anthony Graves, but we hope it can bring him some sense of justice," Laura Popps, deputy counsel for the Office of Chief Disciplinary Counsel, said in a news release. "Whether it is prosecutorial misconduct or other serious allegations of attorney misconduct, our office remains committed to holding lawyers accountable for their actions and obtaining sanctions that protect both the public and the legal profession."

Sebesta could not be immediately reached for comment.

Source: Houston Chronicle, Brian Rogers, June 12, 2015

Ex-DA Who Sent Exoneree Anthony Graves to Death Row Is Disbarred

Charles Sebesta
Should answer to charges of attempted murder: Charles Sebesta
It's been 9 long years since the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals found that Charles Sebesta, the Burleson County DA who prosecuted Anthony Graves for capital murder, had withheld favorable evidence and used false testimony to secure a conviction - a conviction that sent Graves to death row. Graves spent 18 years in prison, most of it in solitary confinement.

Friday, finally, a small measure of justice was served when the State Bar of Texas stripped Sebesta of his law license and formally disbarred him.

It was a stunning reversal of fortune for a man who was, for decades, the most powerful elected official in Burleson and Washington counties. Even after Graves walked free in 2010 and was formally exonerated in 2011, Sebesta continued to impugn his character - telling Texas newspapers as recently as last January that Graves was guilty of murder. Until the bar's ruling, he did so with impunity.

Then, last summer - 20 years after Graves' wrongful conviction - the bar's chief disciplinary counsel determined that there was "just cause" to believe that the former prosecutor had engaged in misconduct. This finding followed a lengthy investigation, which the bar conducted after Graves brought a grievance against Sebesta last January. (Graves was only able to do so because lawmakers passed a bill which changed the existing statute of limitations, allowing exonereees to file such grievances with the bar up to 4 years after their release from prison.)

The legal proceeding that followed was conducted this May behind closed doors, as per Sebesta's request. (Attorneys who are accused of misconduct may elect to have a district court proceeding, which is open to the public, or a private evidentiary panel hearing.) The trial spanned 4 days, and included testimony from Kelly Siegler, the special prosecutor who pronounced Graves an innocent man after re-investigating the case in 2010. Sebesta retained the formidable trial attorney Steve McConnico to defend him. But McConnico was up against the bar's Laura Popps and Beth Stevens, who had prosecuted the professional misconduct matter of former Williamson County DA Ken Anderson, resulting in his disbarment and jail time in 2013 for his conduct in the Michael Morton case.

In a sweeping ruling released this morning, the bar found that Sebesta had violated no fewer than 5 tenets of the Texas Disciplinary Rules of Professional Conduct, including:

--3.03(a)(l ): "A lawyer shall not knowingly make a false statement of material fact or law to a tribunal."

--3.03(a)(5): "A lawyer shall not knowingly offer or use evidence that the lawyer knows to be false."

--3.09(d): "A prosecutor in a criminal case shall make timely disclosure to the defense of all evidence or information known to the prosecutor that tends to negate the guilt of the accused or mitigates the offense ..."

--8.04(a)(l): "A lawyer shall not violate these rules, knowingly assist or induce another to do so, or do so through the acts of another ..." --8.04(a)(3): "A lawyer shall not engage in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation."

When I reached Graves in Houston this morning, he expressed his gratitude to the bar for ensuring that Sebesta had finally faced consequences for his actions. "I never thought that a young, African-American man from the projects could file a grievance against a powerful, white DA in Texas and win," he said.

But he cautioned that a victory in his case alone was not enough. "I think this is a great first step," he said. "But a lot of people in Washington and Burleson counties were prosecuted and convicted by Charles Sebesta, and some of them are still behind bars. All of those cases need to be examined, too."

Was disbarment a sufficient punishment for the man who had sent him to death row, I asked? "I think he should be brought before a court of law to answer to charges of attempted murder," Graves said.

Source: Texas Monthly, Pamela Colloff, June 15, 2015

Report an error, an omission: deathpenaltynews@gmail.com

Most Viewed (Last 7 Days)

Texas: Rodney Reed granted indefinite stay of execution

Nov 16, 1900: Preston John Porter Jr., 16, Lynched and Burned Alive in Limon, Colorado

Texas: James Martinez executed

Calls on Singapore to halt hanging of Malaysian national Abd Helmi at dawn on Friday

Indonésie : dans la prison de Serge Atlaoui, condamné à mort

Malaysia: Four men caned for having gay sex

Sedley Alley: Man executed 13 years ago may be proven innocent by DNA

Judge halts all scheduled federal executions

Thailand: American escapee pronounced dead

Singapore: Malaysian drug trafficker Abd Helmi Ab Halim executed on Friday at Changi Prison