Judge George Gallagher declined to sign an order granting Horner’s motion, which automatically resulted in the request being denied.
Horner’s attorneys argued that extensive media coverage surrounding the case affected potential witnesses and prevented him from receiving a fair trial. The defense claimed the publicity caused key witnesses to refuse to testify.
The judge disagreed and denied the request.
Horner pleaded guilty to capital murder earlier this year, and a jury sentenced him to death in May following a sentencing trial.
What happens next for Tanner Horner?
The denial of Horner’s request for a new trial does not end his appeals process.
Since Horner received a death sentence, his case automatically goes through a direct appeal with the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals. His attorneys can argue that legal errors occurred during the trial that affected the outcome.
If the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals upholds the sentence, Horner can seek review from the U.S. Supreme Court.
RELATED | Former FedEx driver sentenced to death for killing 7-year-old girl after delivery at her Texas home
Death penalty cases can also move into habeas corpus proceedings, where defense attorneys may present new evidence or claims that were not part of the original trial record.
What did Tanner Horner do? What happened to Athena Strand?
A Tarrant County jury took less than 3 hours in May to sentence Horner to death after he pleaded guilty to capital murder.
Jurors unanimously found Horner would pose a continuing threat to society. They determined there were no mitigating circumstances that warranted a sentence of life without parole instead of the death penalty.
During the trial, prosecutor James Stainton said Horner delivered a package of Barbie dolls to Athena's home in Paradise, a town of fewer than 500 residents about 60 miles northwest of Dallas, on Nov. 30, 2022. Stainton told jurors that Horner then kidnapped Athena and assaulted her for more than an hour before using a pair of muddy shoes to "beat the life out of her," holding up the shoes as evidence in court.
"And I think that is key to this entire case. If the facts were not bad enough, if the sexual assault wasn't bad enough, the level of violence that one person can inflict on a child, including stomping them with a pair of shoes," he said.
Texas Ranger Job Espinoza testified that cameras captured Horner stuffing Athena's clothes into a backpack, which was later found at his home, and cleaning the FedEx van after the attack.
Horner told someone over the phone that he cleaned the truck because he threw up in it, according to video footage. Horner also returned to the scene, where a woman told him the area was blocked off because of the kidnapping.
"Are you serious?" he said in video shown to the jury.
After he was caught, Horner spun a "web of lies" and told multiple different stories about what happened to Athena and where her body was during the police investigation, Stainton said.
At one point, Horner told investigators that he took Athena after he accidentally hit her with his vehicle so that she wouldn't report him. He said she wasn't seriously injured, but he panicked and strangled her after she said she would tell her father he hit her. He also concocted an alter ego named "Zero," who he said was responsible for the killing.
Surveillance video showed Horner driving his FedEx delivery truck to Athena's home before returning minutes later with the 7-year-old. The footage captured Horner picking her up and placing her inside the vehicle. After the abduction, Horner covered the truck's internal camera, leaving investigators with audio recordings only for the remainder of the incident.
Athena's 1st questions to Horner were "What are you doing?" and "Are you a kidnapper?” according to the Fort Worth Star-Telegram, NBC DFW and Fox 4. At one point, he told the girl, "You're really pretty. You know that?”
He could be heard on the recording telling the girl, who had begun to cry, to remove her shirt and threatening to hurt her if she screamed. Athena repeatedly told Horner no and asked to go home to her mother. Later, "Jingle Bell Rock" played from the radio as Horner told the screaming Athena to "shut up" or he would hurt her more, reported the Fort Worth Star-Telegram.
Athena was found naked in the Trinity River near an area called Bobo's Crossing, about 12 to 13 miles away from her home, Stainton and former Wise County Sheriff Lane Akin, a witness in the trial, said. Medical examiner Jennifer Dwyer testified that she died of blunt force injuries, smothering, and strangulation.
During closing arguments, defense attorneys urged jurors to spare Horner's life, citing his difficult upbringing, stress at home, and autism diagnosis. Prosecutors argued Horner showed Athena no mercy and asked jurors to impose the death penalty.
Following the sentencing, Athena's uncle, Elijah Strand, addressed Horner directly: "I want you to know that you are nothing. You are a footnote in Athena's story. Her name will forever be celebrated, and everyone will forget you."
Source: USA Today, Brandi D. Addison, August 4, 2026
"One is absolutely sickened, not by the crimes that the wicked have committed,
but by the punishments that the good have inflicted."
— Oscar Wilde
but by the punishments that the good have inflicted."
— Oscar Wilde
Death Penalty News
For a World without the Death Penalty
Comments
Post a Comment
Offensive pro-DP comments will not be published.