Skip to main content

Can the state execute a man who already survived? | Opinion

A second execution would be an unimaginable nightmare for Tony Carruthers and a moral horror for the rest of us.

Tony Carruthers is not supposed to be alive. On May 21, Tennessee set out to execute him.

It failed. Carruthers survived.

He is not the first person to survive an execution in the United States, and he won’t be the last. For Carruthers, the question is: Now what? Will the state seek to arrange a second execution?

A second execution would involve the kind of “superadded” pain that the Supreme Court has used to explain what the Eighth Amendment is meant to prohibit. Moreover, it would simply be an indecent and inhumane thing to do.

Carruthers now joins Romell Broom, Kenneth Smith and Thomas Creech, among others, whose executions by lethal injection were called off when the execution team ran into similar problems. But execution failures have not been confined to that method.

A history of failed executions


In the 19th century hangings occasionally failed. Replacing hangings as this country’s primary method of capital punishment did not put an end to the problem of failed executions. Once, in the twentieth century, the electric chair also failed to kill.

In that case, the state of Louisiana tried to use it in the execution of Willie Francis, a sixteen-year-old Black youth, who had been convicted of murdering a local sheriff. However, when the electric current reached him, he did not die. After that failure, Francis turned to the courts to try to stave off a return to the electric chair. His case ultimately went to the United States Supreme Court, which decided that a second execution would not be cruel.

Francis was electrocuted again in 1947. This time he died.

The precedent set in his case has haunted the case of every execution survivor since. But it was wrong when it was decided, and it is wrong now.

Justice Harold Burton, who dissented in Francis’s case, called what happened to Francis “torture” and said it is the “duty of the state officials to make sure that there was no failure.”

State-sanctioned torture must end


Torture is the right word to describe what happened to Tony Carruthers. “They poked and poked him more than a dozen times in his arms, legs, feet and chest,” First Assistant Federal Public Defender Amy Harwell said.

It was not just the physical pain inflicted on Carruthers as execution team members repeatedly jabbed him with needles that constitutes torture. It's also in the terror of preparing to die, only to have the state fail to do its “duty.”

As anti-death penalty activist Bryan Stevenson reminds us, “Most people can’t possibly imagine the agony of being credibly told that on this date, at this hour, you will be killed, only to go through the process of an execution and be physically abused before being sent back to your cell.”

Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee has given Carruthers a one-year reprieve. But defense lawyers have asked him to halt all executions in the state pending a thorough review of its protocol.



RELATED | Tennessee fails to execute Tony Carruthers after IV difficulties. State won't try again for a year

In the meantime, litigation filed in March 2025 already laid out a compelling case that the administration of lethal injection in Tennessee is constitutionally defective. The execution failure in Carruthers’ case offers even more evidence of its cruelty.

The courts should overrule the Francis decision and make clear that no one should ever face a second trip to the death chamber. A second execution would be an unimaginable nightmare for Tony Carruthers and a moral horror for the rest of us. 

Source: tennessean.com, Austin Sarar, May 30, 2026. Austin Sarat is the William Nelson Cromwell Professor of Jurisprudence and Political Science at Amherst College. 




"One is absolutely sickened, not by the crimes that the wicked have committed,
but by the punishments that the good have inflicted."
— Oscar Wilde
Globe
Death Penalty News For a World without the Death Penalty

Comments

Most viewed (Last 7 days)

Florida set to carry out its record-breaking 20th execution same day as a Texas lethal injection

Florida has carried out more than half of the nation’s 37 executions this year under outgoing Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis, who has made aggressive use of the death penalty like few other governors. Florida is set Thursday to carry out a record-breaking 20th execution of the year on a man convicted of killing a pregnant woman and her husband during a home invasion, while Texas plans to execute a man convicted of killing a Houston jeweler during a $3.6-million diamond robbery.

Death Row Pastor Describes Horror of ‘Botched’ Texas Execution: ‘Torture’

A "botched" execution in Texas on Thursday left a man begging, "Please kill me, kill me," as he screamed for minutes following a lethal injection that should have left him unconscious in seconds, a death row spiritual adviser who witnessed it said. Seventy-year-old Reinaldo Dennes' execution took more than an hour at the penitentiary in Huntsville, as prison staffers struggled to find a suitable vein for the two intravenous needles carrying the lethal dose of the sedative pentobarbital.

Oklahoma dismisses murder charge against former death row inmate Richard Glossip

Glossip had nine execution dates scheduled in nearly 30 years on death row before the U.S. Supreme Court threw out his conviction last year. A murder charge against Richard Glossip, a former death row prisoner who was nearly executed multiple times, was dismissed on Thursday after being granted a retrial in the 1997 killing of his former boss, according to his attorney. He was sentenced to death over the killing of a motel owner named Barry Van Treese, who was beaten to death with a baseball bat. Prosecutors alleged that Treese was killed in a murder-for-hire plot, but Glossip has maintained his innocence for almost 30 years.

Texas executes John Rubio

Texas man who killed 3 children is put to death, hours after an Oklahoma execution James Pavatt was put to death in Oklahoma for Rob Andrew’s killing. In Texas, John Allen Rubio was executed for the deaths of Julissa Quesada, John E. Rubio, and Mary Jane Rubio.  A Texas man convicted of fatally stabbing and beheading 3 young children in a squalid, windowless apartment in 2003 was executed Thursday evening, hours after Oklahoma put another man to death. 

In Florida, a Catholic former death row prisoner works to save those still condemned to death

Florida has been executing criminals at a breakneck pace as Catholics and other advocates urge the government to halt the death penalty there.  Joaquín José Martínez takes the long view when it comes to abolishing the death penalty: “One step at a time.”  Convicted of murder in 1997 and sentenced to death, Martínez—a Catholic—was exonerated in 2001. Since then he has spent years advocating against the death penalty in Florida and elsewhere. 

Oklahoma executes James Pavatt

Pavatt claimed innocence in the slaying of an Oklahoma City advertising executive for insurance money. His co-defendant and former lover Brenda Andrew is also on death row. James Pavatt made no final statement before being executed Thursday for killing his lover’s estranged husband nearly 25 years ago. Pavatt merely shook his head when asked by Oklahoma Department of Corrections Chief of Operations Jason Sparks if he had any last words. Pavatt appeared to share a quick word with Michael Scott, his spiritual advisor, after microphones inside the death chamber had been cut off.

Saudi Arabia executes two nationals for 'terrorism'

Saudi Arabia’s Ministry of Interior announced on Saturday, 14 November 2026, that it had carried out the discretionary ( ta’zir ) death sentences* of two Saudi nationals, Fadel bin Hassan bin Abdullah al-Safwani and Jawad bin Abdullah bin Ali Qureiris (also rendered Qurairees or Qarirees), in the Eastern Province for terrorism-related offenses.

Judge allows Tennessee death row inmates to include botched executions in lawsuit

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (WKRN) — Two failed executions in Tennessee are now at the center of a growing legal battle over the state’s lethal injection protocol after a judge ruled in favor of death row inmates Friday. A Davidson County judge ruled death row inmates can expand their lawsuit to include new allegations stemming from the botched executions of Tony Carruthers and Christa Pike. The original lawsuit, filed in March 2025, argues Tennessee’s death penalty protocol violates the constitutional rights of death row inmates with complex medical conditions. More than one year later, the state then failed to execute two inmates: Tony Carruthers and Christa Pike.

Florida | Governor-elect Byron Donalds says he’ll address death penalty on ‘case-by-case’ basis

Florida has executed 38 people under Gov. Ron DeSantis in the past two years alone, by far the most in the U.S. and the most in Florida history. Among the more formidable responsibilities Byron Donalds will inherit upon being sworn in as governor of Florida in January is signing execution warrants once death-row inmates’ appeals and executive clemency processes have concluded.

Florida executes Thomas Overton

Florida executed its 20th death row inmate this year, breaking the state’s modern-era record Thursday night—as the 71-year-old convicted murderer claimed with his last words that he “never killed anyone.” Thomas Mitchell Overton took his last breath in Florida State Prison’s death chamber 35 years after breaking into a Florida Keys home and fatally strangling a couple and their unborn baby boy. In his final words, he denied the horrifying crimes. “I’ve never sexually assaulted anyone. I never killed anyone." Overton said, adding, “I didn’t kill the MacIvors.”