Florida | Witness offers new exculpating evidence in Pablo Ibar case, defense says

A defense attorney for Pablo Ibar, the man sentenced to life in the June 1994 “Casey’s Nickelodeon” murders, is seeking to have his 2019 conviction vacated after a new witness came forward, alleging two people who were never charged were the true killers.

The “newly discovered evidence,” a sworn affidavit from a witness who was previously not known to Ibar’s defense, could have potentially resulted in a different outcome at Ibar’s trial, attorney Daniel Tibbitt wrote in a court motion filed Sunday.

The witness’s identity is not shared in the motion due to safety concerns. The witness signed an affidavit swearing that two people he knows who are referenced in the court filing only as “A.N. aka El Loco” and “F.B. aka Loeva” are responsible for the murders of Casimir “Butch Casey” Sucharski, owner of Casey’s Nickleodeon nightclub, Sharon Anderson and Marie Rogers.

The three were shot to death during an invasion of Sucharski’s home in Miramar early on the morning of June 26, 1994. The murders were captured on grainy home surveillance video. Ibar, originally from the Basque Country in Spain, was charged with the murders and was tried multiple times, in 1997 ending in a hung jury and in 2000 resulting in a sentence to death row, which was changed to a life sentence. Ibar has always maintained that he is innocent, his attorney wrote.

Prosecutors said a T-shirt found at Sucharski’s home had DNA that matched Ibar, with the probability it was a different Caucasian man at one in 11 million, and one in 35 million among Hispanic men. And the man who was identified as Ibar on the surveillance video had worn a T-shirt covering his head during the murders and removed it afterward, walking directly in front of the camera.

Ibar’s defense repeatedly contested the DNA evidence. Seth Penalver, once Ibar’s co-defendant, was also charged, but his 1999 conviction and subsequent death sentence were also overturned, and at a retrial in 2012 he was found not guilty.

Tibbitt told the South Florida Sun Sentinel on Thursday that the new evidence came after the witness contacted a group of Ibar’s supporters, the Pablo Ibar Association, after Ibar had lost an attempt to appeal in the summer of 2023.

The witness swore in the affidavit that he had met “A.N.” when they worked for drug trafficking organizations in South Florida in the 1990s, according to the motion. In the summer of 1994, A.N. asked the witness to help with a home invasion in the summer of 1994, but he did not participate. Months later while surveilling for a home invasion robbery, the witness heard A.N. bragging about “the home invasion and murders that he and F.B. committed” at a home of a person whose name is redacted in the motion but is clear that it is referencing Sucharski.

The witness said both A.N. and F.B. admitted to the murders and that they were directed by someone identified only as “C.P. aka El Gordo” to enter the house “to get the drugs or money” stemming from a drug-related debt. The witness at the time was an “enforcer” for the Colombian drug organization that the two men worked for, Tibbitt said. The witness was arrested in a federal case two years later and swore in the affidavit that he told both federal and Miami-Dade County law enforcement of A.N.’s and F.B.’s crimes, including the murders, according to the motion.

Tibbitt said after further investigation into the witness’ background and the two men he said had confessed, “everything seemed to check out.” The two men the witness named had been in and out of custody in South Florida for other crimes but were not incarcerated at the time of the Casey’s Nickelodeon murders in 1994, he said.

Tibbitt wrote in the motion that Ibar does not know and has never communicated with the witness nor any of the people the witness mentioned until recently, and the defense would have pursued the lead if they had. “If Pablo had known about this, if his attorneys had known about this, and ultimately if the jury had known about this, he would not have been convicted,” Tibbitt told the Sun Sentinel.

“The evidence against him was always weak and questionable. This certainly would have taken it over the top in terms of reasonable doubt.” Tibbitt is asking that the judge grant an evidentiary hearing to determine whether the witness’ information, though acknowledged as hearsay, is credible and reasonably likely that it would result in a different outcome at retrial.

A spokesperson for the Broward State Attorney’s Office told the South Florida Sun Sentinel that appellate attorneys will file a response in court. A response had not been filed as of Thursday.

Ibar’s defense filed a second motion for post-conviction relief on Monday, also seeking the conviction be vacated, arguing that his trial attorneys were ineffective. Information from the Sun Sentinel archives contributed to this report.

Source: sun-sentinel.com, Angie DiMichele, June 26, 2025

"One is absolutely sickened, not by the crimes that the wicked have committed,
but by the punishments that the good have inflicted."

— Oscar Wilde

Comments

Maldives | Death penalty law for drug trafficking now in effect

MALÉ, Maldives (DPN) — The Maldives has officially brought into force an amendment to its Narcotics Act that introduces the death penalty for large-scale drug trafficking, marking a significant and controversial shift in the island nation’s criminal justice policy. The amended law, which took effect Saturday, March 7, 2026, allows for capital punishment in cases involving the smuggling and importation of specific quantities of illicit substances. The move fulfills a key pledge by President Dr. Mohamed Muizzu’s administration to crack down on the country’s growing narcotics crisis and protect what he has termed the nation’s “100 percent Islamic society.” Thresholds for Capital Punishment Under the new provisions, the death penalty is not a mandatory sentence but an available option for the judiciary when specific criteria are met. The law establishes clear weight thresholds for substances brought into the country: Cannabis: More than 350 grams. Diamorphine (Heroin): More than 250 grams....

Prosecutors seek death penalty in 2 Georgia cases

AUGUSTA, Ga. (WRDW/WAGT) - Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty in two separate Georgia criminal cases. One involves the killing of a Gwinnett County police officer and another is over the death of a 4-year-old girl in Hall County . Kevin Andrews is charged in the death of 25-year-old Gwinnett County Police Officer Pradeep Tamang, who was shot and killed while investigating a credit card fraud case. Authorities said Andrews had an outstanding warrant and shot at officers without warning. Another officer, David Reed, was seriously injured.

Georgia | Death penalty sought against woman in brutal killing of 4-year-old

GAINESVILLE, Ga. — Prosecutors in Hall County are seeking the death penalty against a woman accused of the brutal killing of a 4-year-old girl whose body was found in a parked car last fall. In a court filing Monday, the State announced its intent to pursue capital punishment for Jessica Motes, who faces a litany of charges including malice murder, felony murder, aggravated battery, and first-degree cruelty to children. The case began on Oct. 26, 2025, when authorities discovered the body of 4-year-old Autumn Fox. The child’s remains were found inside the trunk of a vehicle parked at a Sam’s Club in Oakwood, approximately 50 miles northeast of Atlanta.

Alabama | Gov. Ivey commutes Charles “Sonny” Burton’s death sentence

MONTGOMERY, Ala. (WSFA) - Gov. Kay Ivey has commuted the death sentence of Charles “Sonny” Burton, who was set to be executed Thursday. The governor’s office released the following statement: “Governor Kay Ivey on Tuesday announced that she has commuted the death sentence of Charles L. Burton to life in prison with no chance of parole. Mr. Burton was convicted and sentenced to death for the 1991 capital murder of Doug Battle in Talladega, Alabama. As required by law, the governor first reached out to a representative of Mr. Battle’s family. She also notified the attorney general. Governor Ivey’s letter to Alabama Department of Corrections Commissioner John Hamm is attached.

Texas Plans Second Execution of the Year

Cedric Ricks is set to be killed on March 11 Cedric Ricks spoke in his own defense at his 2013 murder trial, something most defendants accused of a terrible crime do not do. Ricks confessed that he had killed his girlfriend, Roxann Sanchez, and her 8-year-old son. He admitted he was aggressive and had trouble controlling his anger, stating that he was “sorry about everything.” The Tarrant County jury was unmoved. Ricks has spent the last 13 years on death row and is scheduled to be executed on March 11.

Supreme Court Denies Alabama Appeal, Allowing New Trial in Death Row Case

The U.S. Supreme Court has cleared the way for a new trial for one of Alabama’s longest-serving people on death row after declining to review a lower court ruling that prosecutors violated his constitutional rights by intentionally rejecting Black jurors. According to an article written by the Associated Press, one of the longest-serving death row inmates in Alabama might receive a new trial after the U.S. Supreme Court rejected the state’s appeal of a lower court’s ruling that prosecutors had violated his rights by intentionally rejecting Black jurors. According to the article, on Monday, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to review the ruling from the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. This decision paved the way for Michael Sockwell, the 63-year-old death row inmate, to receive a new trial.

Florida executes Billy Kearse

Florida executes man who killed Fort Pierce police officer during 1991 traffic stop Moments before receiving a lethal injection, Billy Kearse asked for forgiveness from the family of Danny Parrish, whose widow said she found peace after a "long, long 35 years.” A man convicted of fatally shooting a police officer with his own service weapon during a traffic stop was executed Tuesday evening, becoming the third person put to death by Florida this year after a record 19 executions in 2025.

Missouri Man Said DNA Test Could Prove Innocence. He Was Executed Before a Court Ruled.

Lance Shockley died by lethal injection last year. State courts have rejected prisoners’ requests for DNA testing in recent years. Lance Shockley, a man on death row in Missouri, wanted items from the crime scene to undergo DNA testing to potentially prove his innocence. The court scheduled proceedings on his request — but the date set was for two days after his execution. Patty Prewitt can’t have her DNA tested — and fully clear her name — because her sentence was commuted and she is no longer in prison. And others, including Lamar McVay, who is serving 30 years for a robbery, can’t even get an answer from the state on his DNA testing request. He's still awaiting a ruling on a motion he filed in September 2022.

Florida | Governor DeSantis signs death warrant in 2008 murder case

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — Governor Ron DeSantis has signed a death warrant for Michael L. King, setting an execution date of March 17, 2026, at 6 p.m. King was convicted and sentenced to death for the 2008 kidnapping, sexual battery and murder of Denise Amber Lee, a 21-year-old North Port mother. On January 17, 2008, Michael Lee King abducted 21-year-old Denise Amber Lee from her North Port home by forcing her into his green Chevrolet Camaro. He drove her around while she was bound, including to his cousin's house to borrow tools like a shovel. King took her to his home, where he sexually battered her, then placed her in the backseat of his car. Later that evening, he drove to a remote area, shot her in the face, and buried her nude body in a shallow grave. Her remains were discovered two days later. During the crime, multiple 9-1-1 calls were made, but communication breakdowns between emergency dispatch centers delayed the response. The case drew national attention and prompted w...

Chinese courts conclude trials of 2 criminal gangs from northern Myanmar, 16 sentenced to death

Chinese courts have concluded the trials of 2 major criminal groups based in northern Myanmar involved in telecom and online fraud, the Supreme People's Court (SPC) said Thursday. At a press conference held by the SPC, it was revealed that by the end of 2025, courts across the country had concluded first-instance trials of over 27,000 cases related to telecom fraud operations in northern Myanmar, with more than 41,000 returned suspects sentenced. Notably, among the trials of the so-called "4 major families" criminal gangs -- which had drawn widespread domestic and international attention -- those of the Ming and Bai groups have completed all judicial proceedings.

Death Penalty News

Search This Blog