Skip to main content

Nine Tennessee Death Row Prisoners Challenge State’s One-Drug Lethal Injection Protocol, Citing ​“High Risk of Torturous Death”

On March 14, 2025, a group of nine death row pris­on­ers in Tennessee filed a law­suit chal­leng­ing the state’s sole use of pen­to­bar­bi­tal in its revised lethal injec­tion pro­to­col, argu­ing it cre­ates a ​“high risk of a tor­tur­ous death.” In December 2024, the Tennessee Department of Correction (TDOC) com­plet­ed a mul­ti-year lethal injec­tion pro­to­col review and announced that instead of the pre­vi­ous three-drug pro­to­col, the state would shift to rely on just one drug: pen­to­bar­bi­tal. 

Earlier this month, the Tennessee Supreme Court sched­uled exe­cu­tion dates for four indi­vid­u­als begin­ning in May 2025: Oscar Smith (May 22), Byron Black (August 5), Donald Middlebrooks (September 24), and Harold Nichols (December 11).

Both Mr. Smith and Mr. Black are par­ties to the law­suit, which alleges pen­to­bar­bi­tal is ​“a poi­son that has been shown through recent evi­dence to pose a high risk of a tor­tur­ous death, par­tic­u­lar­ly if obtained, stored, han­dled, and/​or admin­is­tered incor­rect­ly.” 

According to the claim, the department’s ​“cul­ture of non­com­pli­ance, when com­bined with the risk-prone nature of pen­to­bar­bi­tal poi­son­ing as a method of exe­cu­tion, cre­ates a high risk that a per­son receiv­ing a lethal injec­tion admin­is­tered by TDOC will be tor­tured to death.” 

The law­suit also points to a 2020 review of 200 autop­sies of indi­vid­u­als exe­cut­ed by lethal injec­tion, includ­ing 58 pris­on­ers exe­cut­ed by pen­to­bar­bi­tal. Of these 58 peo­ple, 49 of them ​“expe­ri­enced pul­monary ede­ma, a con­di­tion in which flu­id accu­mu­lates in the air spaces of the lungs.” 

Pulmonary ede­ma, the fil­ing explains, ​“can cre­ate a sense of suf­fo­cat­ing or drown­ing that has been likened by experts to the sen­sa­tion inten­tion­al­ly induced by the prac­tice of water­board­ing — an unam­bigu­ous form of out­right tor­ture.” 

The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), under then-Attorney General Merrick Garland with­drew the sin­gle-use of pen­to­bar­bi­tal in fed­er­al exe­cu­tions just weeks after Tennessee announced its new pro­to­col based on what he called ​“sig­nif­i­cant uncer­tain­ty” about whether exe­cu­tions by pen­to­bar­bi­tal cause unnec­es­sary pain and suffering.

The evi­dence keeps pil­ing up to show that pen­to­bar­bi­tal poi­son­ing is excru­ci­at­ing­ly painful…Tennessee appears to have picked this method only because they were able to get their hands on pen­to­bar­bi­tal, not because its use for exe­cu­tions com­plies with the Constitution or state law.
— Amy Harwell, attor­ney rep­re­sent­ing nine death row pris­on­ers in chal­lenge to Tennessee’s pentobarbital protocol.

The law­suit also con­tests TDOC’s ​“12-hour black­out” pol­i­cy, which man­dates that the war­den “[e]nsure non-con­tact vis­its and phone calls — exclud­ing vis­its and calls from the inmate’s attor­ney of record — are con­clud­ed” 12 hours ahead of the sched­uled exe­cu­tion. 

This por­tion of the new pro­to­col pre­vents pris­on­ers from inter­act­ing with friends, fam­i­ly, and any spir­i­tu­al advi­sors dur­ing the last 12 hours of their life. ​“Because the 12-hour black­out con­cludes with the exe­cu­tion of the restrict­ed per­son, the 12-Hour Blackout pol­i­cy is a restric­tion on the individual’s abil­i­ty to com­mu­ni­cate his thoughts and feel­ings as he faces death,” says the lawsuit.

In May 2022, Governor Bill Lee paused all exe­cu­tions and called for an ​“inde­pen­dent review” of the state’s exe­cu­tion pro­to­col to address a ​“tech­ni­cal over­sight” that led him to halt Oscar Smith’s exe­cu­tion less than a half-hour before it was sched­uled to be car­ried out on April 21, 2022. 

Gov. Lee retained for­mer U.S. Attorney Ed Stanton to con­duct a review of Tennessee’s exe­cu­tion pro­to­col after cor­rec­tions depart­ment offi­cials failed to test the exe­cu­tion drugs for bac­te­r­i­al endo­tox­ins before Mr. Smith’s exe­cu­tion. Mr. Stanton’s inde­pen­dent review, which exam­ined all exe­cu­tions car­ried out in the state between 2018 and 2022, and released in December 2022, found that the same lax over­sight that occurred in the lead up to Mr. Smith’s exe­cu­tion had also occurred in the prepa­ra­tions for the sev­en pre­vi­ous exe­cu­tions. 

Between 2018 and 2022, two peo­ple were exe­cut­ed by lethal injec­tion; five were exe­cut­ed by elec­tro­cu­tion, but the state pre­pared lethal injec­tion drugs in case they changed their choice of exe­cu­tion method; and one exe­cu­tion was called off after preparations begun.

According to Mr. Stanton’s report, the state’s pre­vi­ous exe­cu­tion pro­to­col required that the drugs be test­ed for poten­cy, steril­i­ty, and endo­tox­in con­t­a­m­i­na­tion, but TDOC repeat­ed­ly vio­lat­ed that require­ment, test­ing for endo­tox­ins in only one of eight pre­pared dos­es of lethal injec­tion. Ahead of one of the exe­cu­tions, TDOC failed to con­duct any test­ing, and in anoth­er, the drug failed poten­cy test­ing. 

Several reforms were rec­om­mend­ed in Mr. Stanton’s report, includ­ing the acqui­si­tion of a phar­ma­ceu­ti­cal expert to guide the lethal injec­tion process, dis­clo­sure of exe­cu­tion pro­to­col to drug providers, and for­ma­tion of a review team for pre-exe­cu­tion test­ing data. 

In response, Gov. Lee announced four spe­cif­ic actions his admin­is­tra­tion would imple­ment: lead­er­ship restruc­tur­ing with­in TDOC, appoint­ment of a per­ma­nent TDOC com­mis­sion­er in January 2023, pro­to­col revi­sion (in col­lab­o­ra­tion with the Governor’s and Attorney General’s offices), and com­pre­hen­sive train­ing review relat­ed to the updat­ed pro­to­cols and operational modifications.

Tennessee’s last exe­cu­tion was car­ried out in February 2020, with the elec­tro­cu­tion of Nicholas Sutton.

Source: Death Penalty Information Center, Staff, March 18, 2025




"One is absolutely sickened, not by the crimes that the wicked have committed,
but by the punishments that the good have inflicted."
— Oscar Wilde


Comments

Most viewed (Last 7 days)

Oklahoma executes James Pavatt

Pavatt claimed innocence in the slaying of an Oklahoma City advertising executive for insurance money. His co-defendant and former lover Brenda Andrew is also on death row. James Pavatt made no final statement before being executed Thursday for killing his lover’s estranged husband nearly 25 years ago. Pavatt merely shook his head when asked by Oklahoma Department of Corrections Chief of Operations Jason Sparks if he had any last words. Pavatt appeared to share a quick word with Michael Scott, his spiritual advisor, after microphones inside the death chamber had been cut off.

Two men set to be executed in Texas and Oklahoma today

The U.S. was preparing to carry out two executions on Thursday, one in Oklahoma and one in Texas. In Texas, the condemned man is John Allen Rubio, 46, who is set to be put to death at the state prison in Huntsville. He was convicted of beheading three young children he was raising in a 2003 killing that rattled a community along the U.S.-Mexico border. The other man facing execution is James Pavatt, 73, who is set to die by lethal injection at Oklahoma's state penitentiary in McAlester.

Texas executes John Rubio

Texas man who killed 3 children is put to death, hours after an Oklahoma execution James Pavatt was put to death in Oklahoma for Rob Andrew’s killing. In Texas, John Allen Rubio was executed for the deaths of Julissa Quesada, John E. Rubio, and Mary Jane Rubio.  A Texas man convicted of fatally stabbing and beheading 3 young children in a squalid, windowless apartment in 2003 was executed Thursday evening, hours after Oklahoma put another man to death. 

Oklahoma dismisses murder charge against former death row inmate Richard Glossip

Glossip had nine execution dates scheduled in nearly 30 years on death row before the U.S. Supreme Court threw out his conviction last year. A murder charge against Richard Glossip, a former death row prisoner who was nearly executed multiple times, was dismissed on Thursday after being granted a retrial in the 1997 killing of his former boss, according to his attorney. He was sentenced to death over the killing of a motel owner named Barry Van Treese, who was beaten to death with a baseball bat. Prosecutors alleged that Treese was killed in a murder-for-hire plot, but Glossip has maintained his innocence for almost 30 years.

Oklahoma Death Row inmate James Pavatt scheduled to be executed Thursday

James Pavatt is scheduled to be executed on Thursday for the 2001 killing of an Oklahoma City man. OKLAHOMA CITY—Oklahoma Death Row inmate James Pavatt is set to be executed for the 2001 murder of advertising executive Rob Andrew. His execution is scheduled for Nov. 12, 2026. In 2004, Pavatt and his lover/co-conspirator, Brenda Andrew, were sentenced to death for planning the killing of her estranged husband in an attempt to claim his $800,000 life insurance policy. Brenda is the only woman on Oklahoma’s death row.

California | Former San Quentin warden regrets partaking in executions, calls for replacing death penalty with life without parole

The former warden of San Quentin prison in California, Jeanne Woodford, regrets having taken part in executions and has called for replacing the death penalty with life without the possibility of parole.  In an op-ed in the Los Angeles Times, Woodford notes that after each execution, “someone on the staff would ask, ‘Is the world safer because of what we did tonight?’ We knew the answer: No.” The full article can be found below.

Saudi Arabia executes two nationals for 'terrorism'

Saudi Arabia’s Ministry of Interior announced on Saturday, 14 November 2026, that it had carried out the discretionary ( ta’zir ) death sentences* of two Saudi nationals, Fadel bin Hassan bin Abdullah al-Safwani and Jawad bin Abdullah bin Ali Qureiris (also rendered Qurairees or Qarirees), in the Eastern Province for terrorism-related offenses.

Florida | Governor-elect Byron Donalds says he’ll address death penalty on ‘case-by-case’ basis

Florida has executed 38 people under Gov. Ron DeSantis in the past two years alone, by far the most in the U.S. and the most in Florida history. Among the more formidable responsibilities Byron Donalds will inherit upon being sworn in as governor of Florida in January is signing execution warrants once death-row inmates’ appeals and executive clemency processes have concluded.

Judge allows Tennessee death row inmates to include botched executions in lawsuit

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (WKRN) — Two failed executions in Tennessee are now at the center of a growing legal battle over the state’s lethal injection protocol after a judge ruled in favor of death row inmates Friday. A Davidson County judge ruled death row inmates can expand their lawsuit to include new allegations stemming from the botched executions of Tony Carruthers and Christa Pike. The original lawsuit, filed in March 2025, argues Tennessee’s death penalty protocol violates the constitutional rights of death row inmates with complex medical conditions. More than one year later, the state then failed to execute two inmates: Tony Carruthers and Christa Pike.

Iran executes three more January protesters accused of spying for Israel, US

In a statement, the judiciary said that “the death sentences of Hassan Deoband, Hamid Kazemi, and Reza Zangana were carried out on charges of ‘participating in operational action for the infamous Zionist regime and the United States and hostile groups.’” ERBIL, Kurdistan Region of Iraq – Iran on Sunday executed three more protesters over their involvement in the nationwide demonstrations in January, the judiciary announced, accusing them of spying for the United States and Israel and destroying infrastructure.