Skip to main content

The Execution of Toforest Johnson: Alabama to go ahead with killing of 'innocent' man despite outcry

BIRMINGHAM, ALABAMA: The state of Alabama is seeking to execute Toforest Johnson despite an outcry from prosecutors, investigators, and jury, who contend that he may not have committed the crime for which he was convicted.

Johnson, 49, was sentenced to death in 1998 for the execution-style shooting of William Hardy, a deputy sheriff for Jefferson County, who was shot twice in the back of the head in 1995 while serving as an off-duty security guard at a hotel.

Just a few hours after Hardy’s body was discovered in the hotel, Johnson was arrested with four other black men.

Three were released after initial interrogation but officials kept Johnson and co-defendant Adragus Ford in custody despite having no witnesses or forensic evidence to tie them to the murder.

With little more to go on, officials offered a $5,000 award for information, which resulted in a rush of tips from the public.

How was Toforest Johnson found guilty of William Hardy’s murder?


After the reward announcement, the vital tip that landed Johnson behind bars came from a 15-year-old girl, who eventually admitted to making up hundreds of lies.

This girl’s “mother contacted police and said she had information about the murder, then immediately hired a lawyer trying to pursue the reward money," said Beth Shelburne, an investigator who has covered Johnson's case for over three years.

Shelburne told Daily Mail that once the 15-year-old girl's testimony was disproved, detectives went to another witness, a so-called earwitness, a mother whose teenage daughter had assisted her boyfriend in making three-way conversations from the jail without using up his allotted quarters.

The mother claimed to have overheard Johnson confessing to the crime during one of these conversations. This earwitness "became the star witness - even though this was the only evidence connecting Toforest to the murder," Shelburne said.

The woman who testified against Johnson admitted to having never met him or heard his voice before the phone call.

Shelburne said the person Toforest was calling told her that "he said none of the things that she testified to."

The investigator added that the woman first told investigators a light version of the phone call, but over the course of many trials, it intensified and evolved, and the woman eventually testified to gory details of the supposed confession.

As a result of Toforest's low income and deep-south upbringing, the state provided him with a lawyer since he couldn't afford one.

"That is appallingly low," Shelbourne said, adding, "In contrast, Toforest's co-defendant Adragus Ford's family were able to hire one of the top criminal defense attorneys in the southeast... and Adragus was acquitted."

For the same crime, the two were granted separate trials, and the prosecution's arguments in each instance contrasted starkly with each other. Eventually, Ford was acquitted, and Johnson's first trial resulted in a hung jury.

Why do authorities believe Toforest Johnson is innocent?


Johnson has since not seen freedom despite the defense presenting 10 different witnesses who testified that he was partying in a club on the other side of the city at the time of Hardy's shooting.

Although he denies recalling the accusations against him, the eavesdropper's evidence was sufficient for the prosecution to get not only a guilty judgment but also a conviction for the death penalty.

Nearly 19 years later, documents that were reportedly "misfiled" showed the so-called "earwitness" received $5,000 for testifying in court, information that was never made known to the jury.

"Was my dad's life worth a $5,000 cheque?" Johnson’s heartbroken daughter Shanaye Poole lamented.

"Clearly, she couldn't have been considering that this person was a son, he's a father, now he's a grandfather, he was a brother, and he had all that taken away from him," she added.

Another aspect of the trial that has raised questions about the conviction was the prosecution's apparent determination to get a guilty plea.

They arrested four other black men and one black girl for crimes connected to Hardy's murder while putting up different theories about who shot Hardy in each instance.

At trial, the state alleged that each of the men was the only killer because forensic evidence proved there was only one assailant.

Notably, an Alabama death sentence conviction may only be reversed by the state's attorney general, who is still supporting the man's execution.

However, Bill Baxley, a former conservative Attorney General of the state, is one of the loudest critics condemning the scheduled execution.

Baxley says the case landed on his radar when his son, an attorney, asked him to review it.

Although initially skeptical—especially given the prevalence of declarations of innocence among death row inmates—Baxley claims that after carefully reading the court records, he was astounded.

"I couldn't believe what I was reading," he told the Associated Press. "I was just dumbfounded that, in Alabama, a case as weak as that would have gotten to the jury, much less a death sentence... It was just unconscionable for this to stand."

Baxley's calls for a retrial come as District Attorney Carr has urged officials to grant Johnson a review. Juror Monique Hicks also voiced Johnson’s innocence saying, "I think we convicted an innocent man. I feel grief deep in my soul."

The distressing sentiment was echoed by fellow juror Jay Crane, who admitted: "They don't have the right person in prison."

Despite languishing on death row for decades, Johnson's loved ones said he has always remained "hopeful", with his landmark case set to be heard by the US Supreme Court on October 2.

Source: meaww.com, Piyush Arora, September 17, 2023


_____________________________________________________________________




_____________________________________________________________________


FOLLOW US ON:












HELP US KEEP THIS BLOG UP & RUNNING!



"One is absolutely sickened, not by the crimes that the wicked have committed,
but by the punishments that the good have inflicted."


— Oscar Wilde

Most viewed (Last 7 days)

Indiana executes Benjamin Ritchie

Death row inmate Benjamin Ritchie was executed by lethal injection shortly after midnight Tuesday at the Indiana State Prison in Michigan City, according to Department of Correction officials. The death sentence was carried out nearly 25 years after Ritchie shot and killed Beech Grove law enforcement officer William Toney. The condemned man had been on death row since his conviction in 2002. Details about the 45-year-old’s execution were sparse. No independent media representatives were permitted to witness the process.

Iran | Singer Amirhossein Tataloo at Grave Risk of Execution for Blasphemy

Iran Human Rights (IHRNGO); May 17, 2025: Asghar Jahangir, Iran’s Judiciary spokesman announced today that the blasphemy death conviction of Amirhossein Maghsoudloo, known as Tataloo, has been upheld by the Supreme Court and sent for enforcement. The singer’s defence lawyer, Majid Naghshi, previously reported filing a judicial review request. Reiterating its opposition to the death penalty in all circumstances, Iran Human Rights considers the use of this inhumane punishment for charges such as blasphemy to be a flagrant violation of international human rights law and calls on civil society and the international community not remain silent about Amirhossein Maghsoudlou’s death penalty.

Indiana man set for execution in state's second since 2009

MICHIGAN CITY, Ind. (AP) — An Indiana man convicted in the 2000 killing of a police officer is set to receive a lethal injection early Tuesday in the state’s second execution in 15 years. Benjamin Ritchie, 45, has been on death row for more than 20 years after being convicted in the fatal shooting of Beech Grove Police Officer Bill Toney during a foot chase. Unless there’s last-minute court action, Ritchie is scheduled to be executed “before the hour of sunrise” at the Indiana State Prison in Michigan City, according to state officials.

South Carolina | Death row inmate seeks to volunteer to die after friends are executed

A South Carolina death row inmate has said he wants to become his own attorney, a decision that would likely lead to his own execution after his best friend and four fellow inmates were put to death in less than a year. A 45-day delay in James Robertson's request was ordered by a federal judge, allowing time for a different lawyer to talk to him and make sure he really wants to fire his own attorneys. The consequences of his decision are likely to be lethal. The 51-year-old Robertson has been on death row since 1999 after killing both his parents in their Rock Hill home. He beat his father with the claw end of a hammer and a baseball bat and stabbed his mother. He then tried to make it look like a robbery in hopes he would get his part of their $2.2 million estate, prosecutors said.

Tennessee executes Oscar Franklin Smith

The state of Tennessee has executed Oscar Franklin Smith, sentenced to death for the 1989 killings of his estranged wife Judith Robirds Smith and her two teenage sons, Chad Burnett and Jason Burnett, in Nashville. Smith, 75, was killed by a fatal dose of the drug pentobarbital injected into his veins at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution. He was pronounced dead at 10:47 a.m. May 22. Smith's execution marks a return to capital punishment in Tennessee after the governor instituted a moratorium on the state's most severe penalty. It had been five years since a Tennessee prisoner died by execution and six years since the state killed someone by lethal injection.

Oscar Franklin Smith, Tennessee death row inmate, declines to select execution method

Oscar Franklin Smith, a Tennessee death row inmate scheduled for execution on May 22, will die by lethal injection if the process moves forward. Smith, who was asked to choose between lethal injection and the electric chair, declined to pick, his attorney Kelley Henry, a supervisory assistant federal public defender, said. When an inmate does not choose, the method defaults to lethal injection. It's not the first time Smith has been given this grim decision and declined. That decision to not choose ultimately saved his life for three more years.

Florida executes Glen Rogers

Florida executes suspected serial killer once eyed for possible link to the OJ Simpson case  A suspected serial killer once scrutinized for a possible link to the O.J. Simpson case that riveted the nation in the 1990s was executed Thursday in Florida for the murder of a woman found dead in a Tampa motel room.  Glen Rogers, 62, received a lethal injection at Florida State Prison near Starke and was pronounced dead at 6:16 p.m., authorities said. He was convicted in Florida of the 1995 murder of Tina Marie Cribbs, a 34-year-old mother of 2 he had met at a bar.

Iran | Convicted killer hanged in Tabriz. Execution carried out by his uncle, who was plaintiff in the case

Iran Human Rights (IHRNGO); May 10, 2025: Hassan Saei, a man on death row for murder, was executed in Tabriz Central Prison. His execution was carried out by his uncle, who was the plaintiff in the case. According to information obtained by Iran Human Rights, a man was hanged in Tabriz Central Prison on 6 May 2025. His identity has been established as Hassan Saei who was sentenced to qisas (retribution-in-kind) for murder by the Criminal Court. An informed source told IHRNGO: “Hassan Saei was arrested for the murder of his cousin and his maternal uncle carried out the execution.”

Texas Set to Execute Fourth Inmate of the Year

Matthew Johnson was convicted of the 2012 murder of Nancy Harris in Dallas County. Matthew Johnson’s guilt was never in question. On the stand during his 2013 trial, he admitted to the crime that landed him on death row. The attack—an early morning robbery and murder in a populous Dallas suburb—was also caught on camera. Johnson is scheduled to be executed by the State of Texas on May 20, exactly 13 years to the day after he robbed a Fina Whip-In convenience store in Garland and set the store clerk on fire. Johnson was convicted of the murder of Nancy Harris, the 76-year-old clerk. 

Texas executes Matthew Lee Johnson

Texas man is executed 13 years to the day of a store robbery in which he set a clerk on fire  A Texas man was executed Tuesday evening, 13 years to the day of a convenience store robbery in which he set a clerk on fire in a Dallas suburb.  Matthew Lee Johnson, 49, received a lethal injection at the state penitentiary in Huntsville. He was condemned for the May 20, 2012, attack on 76-year-old Nancy Harris, a great-grandmother he splashed with lighter fluid and set ablaze in the suburb of Garland. Badly burned, she died days afterward.