Tennessee execution: Billy Ray Irick tortured to death, expert says in new filing

Editor's note: Reporter Dave Boucher was one of seven state-required media witnesses at Irick's execution. 
Billy Ray Irick felt searing pain akin to torture before he died in a Tennessee prison in August, but steps taken in carrying out his execution blocked signs of suffering, according to a doctor who reviewed information about the lethal injection.
In new court filings entered late Thursday amidst an ongoing legal challenge of Tennessee’s lethal injection protocol, Dr. David Lubarsky said statements from people who witnessed the execution indicated the controversial drug midazolam failed to ensure Irick could not feel pain during his death.
As a result, the death row inmate “experienced the feeling of choking, drowning in his own fluids, suffocating, being buried alive, and the burning sensation caused by the injection of the potassium chloride,” Lubarsky wrote in the filing.
The document also says the state did not follow its own lethal injection protocol, raising questio…

Capital punishment far from dead in Southeast Asia

Screenshot from "Apprentice", by Boo Junfeng (2016)
In July 2013, then-US president Barack Obama sat down with his Vietnamese counterpart, Truong Tan Sang, to talk about Thomas Jefferson. It was Jefferson, Sang said, who had inspired the words of Ho Chi Minh's Proclamation of Independence, which carried as its opener a passage of America's Declaration of Independence.

Just 2 weeks after this high-minded discussion on autonomy and liberty, Vietnam executed a young man named Nguyen Anh Tuan.

It was thought to have been one of the first executions in Vietnam since it changed to death by lethal injection years earlier. But because Vietnam was banned from purchasing "authorized" lethal drugs, Tuan was administered with a home-made concoction that reportedly took 2 hours to kill him.

Between the month of Tuan's death, August 2011, and June 2016, Vietnam executed 439 people, according to one estimate by its Ministry of Public Security, which normally doesn't publish such lists.

In early 2013, one could have been forgiven for thinking that Southeast Asia was moving in the right direction on capital punishment. That year, 2 scholars, David Johnson and Franklin Zimring, described Asia as the "next frontier" in a global movement against capital punishment, since it is where almost 95% of such executions take place.

The death penalty was abolished in Cambodia in 1989, in East Timor a decade later and in the Philippines in 2006. What's more, in countries where capital punishment was still wielded, moratoriums were in place. No executions took place in Indonesia between 2008 and 2013, and none in Singapore between 2010 and 2013. [Figures vary according to sources - DPN].

But since 2013, things have deteriorated. The most recent case was in Thailand, where a convicted murderer was executed by lethal injection on June 18 this year. It was reportedly the country's 1st use of capital punishment since 2009. "The Thai government's many pledges about moving toward abolishing the death penalty clearly meant nothing," said Brad Adams, Asia director at Human Rights Watch, in a recent press release.

In the Philippines, President Rodrigo Duterte has in effect privatized the state's monopoly on the death penalty by allowing for extrajudicial executions of alleged drug users and dealers. He also wants to reinstate capital punishment formally.

Indonesia attracted global headlines when, in 2013, it executed a Malawian national for drug trafficking. It has continued to use capital punishment since. In May, an Australian national, Maria Exposto, was sentenced to death for transporting drugs in Malaysia.

In Vietnam, death sentences have been common in recent years, including for those convicted of corruption.

When defending the use of capital punishment, Indonesian Attorney General Muhammad Prasetyo stated in a 2015 interview: "We are fighting a war against horrible drug crimes that threaten our nation's survival.... I would like to say that an execution is not a pleasant thing. It is not a fun job. But we must do it in order to save the nation from the danger of drugs."

Give ear to 2 parts in this statement, which are fairly representative of the apologia given for the death penalty. First "our nation's survival," and second "it is not a fun job." The latter is a mere euphemism. No one says executions are ever fun, but such a statement provides a sense that the government is forced to commit a "necessary evil," if you will.

But capital punishment is not a necessary evil. It is, in fact, simply a choice. A simplistic reading is that the death penalty lies somewhere between laziness and nihilism. It is an admission by the state that some criminals cannot be reformed or returned to society; worse still, that the state shouldn't even try reforming offenders. In another sense, it is a purely utilitarian response that says killing some prisoners frees up space in Southeast Asia's already overcrowded prisons.

Upon doing away with its peine de mort in 1981, France’s minister of justice and future president Francois Mitterrand* correctly rationalized that capital punishment - represented by the imposing symbolism of the guillotine, the "national razor" - had come to embody "a totalitarian concept of the relationship between the citizen and the state."

Fine words, though finer were those of the 18th-century Italian philosopher Cesare Beccaria, who in his distinguished essay Of Crimes and Punishments wrote of the death penalty as a "war of the whole nation against a citizen whose destruction they consider necessary."

In short, capital punishment allows a government to pretend that it is eradicating people considered a risk to a "nation's survival," a necessary act "in order to save the nation," in the words of the Indonesian attorney general. Or, in the recent words of the leader of Thailand's military junta, General Prayut Chan-ocha, "capital punishment exists to guarantee national peace."

But what it's really about is a state's belief that it can make the ultimate decision on a person's life, that being death. It also allows governments to define what they think are national menaces.

For Vietnam, this means those who want to end the Communist Party's reign and install a multi-party system. In the 2000s, Vietnam reduced the number of crimes that can garner a death sentence, down from 44 to 18. But still on the list are political offenses. Article 109 of the reformed Criminal Code makes it a crime, one punishable by death, to try to overthrow the people's administration - that is, the Communist Party. Article 114 makes it illegal to weaken the apparatus of the party.

In Indonesia, Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand, it means people connected to the drug trade. Indonesia's National Anti-Narcotics Agency reportedly said last year that there were nearly 6 million drug users in the country. That's roughly 2% of the population. In 2016, President Joko Widodo asserted that there were 30 to 50 deaths per day because of drugs, using highly questionable statistics.

But even if true, it pales next to the roughly 550 deaths per day in Indonesia because of tobacco-related illnesses. Yet smoking cigarettes is not considered a threat to the "nation's survival" - maybe because tobacco firms are among the biggest taxpayers in Indonesia.

* François Mitterrand was France's Justice Minister between 1956 and 1957. The death penalty was declared illegal on October 9, 1981 when President François Mitterrand signed an abolition law pushed by Justice Minister Robert Badinter. 

Source: Asia Times, Opinion, David Hutt, June 21, 2018. David Hutt is a Cambodia-based political journalist who has been covering Asian affairs since 2014. He is Southeast Asia columnist for The Diplomat and a regular contributor to international publications.

⚑ | Report an error, an omission, a typo; suggest a story or a new angle to an existing story; submit a piece, a comment; recommend a resource; contact the webmaster, contact us: deathpenaltynews@gmail.com.

Opposed to Capital Punishment? Help us keep this blog up and running! DONATE!

"One is absolutely sickened, not by the crimes that the wicked have committed,
but by the punishments that the good have inflicted." -- Oscar Wilde

Most Viewed (Last 7 Days)

New Hampshire death penalty stands as override falls short

Idaho Department Of Correction Can Keep Lethal Injection Drugs Secret, Judge Says

Double Dose: 2 executions in Texas next week

Florida: Trial for man accused of throwing daughter from Pinellas County bridge delayed

20 Minutes to Death: Record of the Last Execution in France

Nebraska: Convicted killer Anthony Garcia has been sentenced to death

'No Time To Sleep' to depict last day of death penalty inmate

Belarus: the Last Refuge for the Death Penalty in Europe

The Machinery of Death Is Back on the Docket

Tennessee execution: Billy Ray Irick tortured to death, expert says in new filing