Skip to main content

Court: Examine if Austin crime lab botched death penalty evidence

Areli Escobar, Texas
The state’s highest criminal court on Wednesday ordered a closer examination of death row inmate Areli Escobar’s claims that shoddy work by the Austin police crime lab compromised evidence in his case.

Escobar is seeking to have his conviction overturned, and a new trial ordered, after a Travis County jury sentenced him to death in the 2009 sexual assault and stabbing of his neighbor, 17-year-old Bianca Maldonado, an LBJ High School student who was attacked at her East Austin apartment with her year-old son, who survived, nearby.

In a brief order issued Wednesday, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals directed state District Judge David Wahlberg to examine claims that the crime lab produced false or misleading conclusions from DNA evidence in the case, particularly on tests performed on the shirt, jeans and shoes that tied Escobar to the murder.

Defense lawyers also argued that problems discovered at the crime lab after Escobar’s trial — including poorly trained analysts, reports of cross-contamination of samples and questionable analytical methods — tainted the DNA results used to convict Escobar of capital murder.

“Areli Escobar’s capital murder conviction rests on forensic evidence developed by incompetent scientists using bad science,” defense lawyers with the state Office of Capital and Forensic Writs said in his latest appeal.

Austin police officials closed the DNA portion of the crime lab in June 2016 after an audit by the Texas Forensic Science Commission, a state agency that includes leading forensic scientists, found that some staff members were not properly trained and that incorrect methods had been used to examine DNA samples.

“In light of these developments, a comprehensive, independent review of … Mr. Escobar’s case is critical,” defense lawyers told the Court of Criminal Appeals.

The appeals court also ordered Wahlberg to examine two other claims raised by Escobar’s lawyers:

• Whether a fingerprint examiner relied on scientifically invalid methods to link a partial bloody print, found on a lotion bottle 2 feet from Maldonado’s body, to Escobar.

• Whether prosecution experts overstated the significance of cellphone activity — said to put Escobar in the vicinity of Maldonado’s apartment when she was killed — based on calls and texts routed through nearby cell towers.

The case next returns to Wahlberg’s court, where Travis County prosecutors will have a chance to respond to the claims raised by defense lawyers.

Wahlberg can order hearings and briefings to help him form a recommendation on whether he believes the Court of Criminal Appeals should toss out Escobar’s conviction and order a new trial. There is no deadline for the judge to issue his findings or for the appeals court to issue its ruling.

During Escobar’s 2011 trial, prosecutors argued that DNA evidence established his guilt after tests found Maldonado’s blood on his shoes and shirt. In addition, blood on the inside of the victim’s door was linked to Escobar, while tests on blood found in Escobar’s car could not exclude the victim as the source, prosecutors told the jury.

However, tests performed last year on the same evidence were less certain — finding, for example, that the blood on the door could not be interpreted without additional testing, or the samples on the shirt and shoes were inadequate for comparison techniques, defense lawyers said.

“In stark contrast to what the jury heard, the (new testing) demonstrates that the results for these items are inconclusive and do not connect Mr. Escobar to the crime,” the lawyers said.

In addition, the lawyers argued that Escobar, 38, deserves a new trial based on recent information detailing “gross incompetence and negligence at the APD lab.”

Documents showed 11 “contamination incidents” of samples at the lab between 2005 and Escobar’s 2011 trial, they said, including seven by the analyst who tested items in the Maldonado case and three by the forensic scientist who screened evidence for the presence of DNA.

When combined with the forensic science commission’s criticism of the lab’s training and practices, the information raises significant doubts about Escobar’s conviction, they told the appeals court.

“The widespread problems at the lab … call into question all of the DNA evidence in Mr. Escobar’s case,” the lawyers said.

Source: American-Statesman, Chuck Lindell, October 18, 2017


⚑ | Report an error, an omission, a typo; suggest a story or a new angle to an existing story; submit a piece, a comment; recommend a resource; contact the webmaster, contact us: deathpenaltynews@gmail.com.


Opposed to Capital Punishment? Help us keep this blog up and running! DONATE!



"One is absolutely sickened, not by the crimes that the wicked have committed,
but by the punishments that the good have inflicted." -- Oscar Wilde

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Biden Commuted Their Death Sentences. Now What?

As three men challenge their commutations, others brace for imminent prison transfers and the finality of a life sentence with no chance of release. In the days after President Joe Biden commuted his death sentence, 40-year-old Rejon Taylor felt like he’d been reborn. After facing execution for virtually his entire adult life for a crime he committed at 18, he was fueled by a new sense of purpose. He was “a man on a mission,” he told me in an email on Christmas Day. “I will not squander this opportunity of mercy, of life.”

Todd Willingham: Ex-wife says convicted killer confessed

The former wife of a man whose 2004 execution in Texas has become a source of controversy has said he admitted setting the fire that killed their three daughters during a final prison meeting just weeks before he was put to death, according to a Texas newspaper. Stacy Kuykendall, the ex-wife of Cameron Todd Willingham, said in a statement to the Fort Worth Star-Telegram published Sunday that Willingham told her he was upset by threats to divorce him after the new year. The fire that killed the couple's three girls was Dec. 23, 1991. Her last threat to divorce him, she said in a statement, occurred the night before the fire. "He said if I didn't have my girls I couldn't leave him and that I could never have Amber or the twins with anyone else but him," according to the statement from Kuykendall to the newspaper. Willingham went to his death proclaiming his innocence. And over the years, she has offered differing accounts. A Tribune investigation in 2004 showed the...

Saudi Arabia executes Somali national, Saudi citizen

Mogadishu (HOL) — Saudi authorities executed a Somali national convicted of drug smuggling and a Saudi citizen found guilty of murder, the Ministry of Interior announced on Sunday. The Somali national, identified as Mohamed Nur Hussein Ja'al, was arrested for attempting to smuggle hashish into Saudi Arabia. A specialized court found him guilty and sentenced him to death under tazir punishment, a discretionary ruling in Islamic law for severe crimes. After an appeal, the Supreme Court upheld the sentence, and a royal decree authorized the execution, which was carried out on Sunday in Najran, southern Saudi Arabia.

Louisiana man with execution date next month dies at Angola

Christopher Sepulvado, the 81-year-old man who was facing execution next month for the 1992 murder of his stepson, died overnight at Louisiana State Penitentiary in Angola, according to his attorney. Shawn Nolan, who had represented Sepulvado, said his client had had a gangrenous leg amputated last week at a New Orleans hospital. Doctors had determined Sepulvado, who had multiple serious ailments, was terminally ill and recommended hospice care at the time a judge set his execution date for March 17, according to his attorney.

Alabama executes Demetrius Frazier

Alabama puts man to death in the nation's fourth execution using nitrogen gas ATMORE, Ala. — A man convicted of murdering a woman after breaking into her apartment as she slept was put to death Thursday evening in Alabama in the nation's fourth execution using nitrogen gas. Demetrius Frazier, 52, was pronounced dead at 6:36 p.m. at a south Alabama prison for his murder conviction in the 1991 rape and killing of Pauline Brown, 41. It was the first execution in Alabama this year and the third in the U.S. in 2025, following a lethal injection Wednesday in Texas and another last Friday in South Carolina.

Texas executes Steven Nelson

A man has been executed by lethal injection in the US state of Texas for the 2011 murder of a pastor that he insisted he did not commit. Steven Nelson, 37, spent more than a dozen years on death row for the murder of Clint Dobson, 28, during a robbery of the NorthPointe Baptist Church in Arlington, near Dallas. Judy Elliott, the church secretary, was also badly beaten during the robbery but survived.

U.S. | AG Bondi orders federal inmate transferred for execution

President Donald Trump's newly installed attorney general, Pam Bondi, has ordered the transfer of a federal inmate to Oklahoma so he can be executed, following through on Trump's sweeping executive order to more actively support the death penalty. Bondi this week directed the Federal Bureau of Prisons to transfer inmate George John Hanson, 60, so that he can be executed for his role in the kidnapping and killing of a 77-year-old woman in Tulsa in 1999.

Singapore Court Of Appeal Grants Stay Of Execution To Pannir Selvam

SINGAPORE, Feb 19 (Bernama) -- Singapore Court of Appeal on Wednesday has granted Malaysian death row inmate Pannir Selvam Pranthaman a stay of execution just hours before he was scheduled to be executed on Thursday (Feb 20). Judge of the Appellate Division Woo Bih Li, in his judgment, said the stay was granted pending the determination of Pannir Selvam’s Post-Appeal Applications in Capital Cases (PACC) application.

Singapore | Pannir set to be executed on Feb 20

His former lawyer, M Ravi, says the only recourse now is for the Malaysian government to file an urgent application to the International Court of Justice challenging the execution. PETALING JAYA: Pannir Selvam Pranthaman, the 38-year-old Malaysian convicted of drug trafficking in Singapore, will be executed on Thursday (Feb 20), according to his former lawyer, M Ravi. In a Facebook post today, Ravi said Pannir’s sister told him that she had received a letter from the prison today confirming his execution in four days. Ravi claimed that during his time representing Pannir in 2020, Singapore’s prison authorities improperly forwarded confidential information on 13 inmates to the Singapore Attorney-General’s Chambers.

South Carolina death row inmate chooses firing squad as execution method

Brad Sigmon, 67, is scheduled to be killed on March 7 A South Carolina death row inmate has chosen to be executed by a firing squad, which would make him only the fourth inmate in the U.S. to die by this execution method. Brad Sigmon, 67, who is scheduled to be killed on March 7, informed state officials on Friday that he wishes to die by firing squad rather than by lethal injection or the electric chair, citing, in part, the prolonged suffering the three inmates previously executed in the state had faced when they were killed by lethal injection.