Bali Nine pair Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran plead to live

Myuran Sukumaran (left)
Andrew Chan (right)

BALI Nine ringleaders Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran (left) will appear in court as their final appeals against the death penalty begin.

It is expected the pair will tell judges of their regret and their rehabilitation since being jailed five years ago and of their determination to now turn their lives around.

Their judicial review comes as fellow Bali Nine member Scott Rush's appeal continues, after Australian Federal Police chiefs last week gave evidence on his behalf.

While Rush was a courier, caught with the drugs strapped to him, both Chan and Sukumaran have been described as the ringleaders and organisers.

Their judicial review is based more on human rights grounds. Both claim legal errors in the original judgments, and are also relying on their rehabilitation in Kerobokan jail to help them persuade judges to let them live.

In the past year they have set up programs for their fellow prisoners, including English, computer, graphics and art classes.

The jail's governor, Siswanto, has agreed to give evidence on their behalf.

For the first time since their arrest, both men are admitting their guilt and their roles in the heroin trafficking ring. Previously, both had refused to admit any role - which they say was based on bad legal advice after their arrests and in their trials.

Psychiatric reports on both, by Prof Paul Mullen, form part of the appeal documents lodged with Denpasar District Court.

Of Chan, Prof Mullen writes that he had been abusing cannabis since his teens and that since being in jail he has been drug-free for the first time since he was 16.

It also tells of Chan's religious conversion. He is now studying theology inside jail and helps to run a church service for inmates.

Prof Mullen's report about Sukumaran tells of a "disturbed and disrupted early childhood" and of his exposure, for the first time in jail, to the evil effects of drugs.

"He has been brought into contact, as never before, with the addicts and their families whose lives have been ruined. He described considerable remorse and continuing feelings of guilt about his offending and involvement in drug smuggling," he said.

The appeal documents argue that the death penalty should be used only for the most serious of crimes, and submits that drugs are not among these.

It is expected that four witnesses will be called as the hearing progresses, including the jail boss and Prof Mullen.

Source: HeraldSun.com.au, September 21, 2010

'Bali Nine' ring leaders make final appeal

The two leaders of an Australian drug running group known as the Bali Nine have appeared in an Indonesian court during the first hearing into their final appeal against the death penalty.

Lawyers for Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran have asked for the pair's sentences to be reduced to 20 years in prison.

Sukumaran told Denpasar District Court that he regretted his involvement in the heroin-smuggling ring.

"I can't say how deep my feelings are about my actions in the past. I know I have to change the direction of my life," he said.

Their lawyers will argue that the death penalty is unconstitutional.

Source: Australia Network News, September 21, 2010

Chan and Sukumaran beg for their lives

Bali Nine ringleaders Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran have begged an Indonesian court for forgiveness and a second chance at life.

As part of their final appeal against their death sentences the Sydney men on Tuesday told the Denpasar District Court of their deep remorse for their roles in a 2005 attempt to smuggle more than eight kilograms of heroin from Bali to Australia.

Speaking in Indonesian as a mark of respect to the court, they told the panel of three judges they had changed their ways and wanted the chance to be useful members of society.

Sukumaran, 29, said he was "truly, deeply sorry" for his actions and was now trying to lead a generous life, not a selfish one.

"I now realise that before I was arrested I was thoughtless and ignorant," he said.

"Before I was arrested I had no idea how harmful my drug crime would be.

"I did not think about the impact, I did not know any drug addicts and I never thought seriously about the consequences of my actions.

"From the bottom of my heart I can honestly say I am now a different person and a reformed person."

Chan and Sukumaran have both been running education courses for fellow inmates inside Bali's Kerobokan Prison as part of their efforts to rehabilitate.

Chan, 26, said he knew he couldn't change the "stupid things" he did in the past.

"But I have genuinely changed my behaviour and I really want to focus on what I can do now and in the future," he said.

Chan, who has also been studying for a Bachelor's Degree in Theology while in prison, said he hoped to become a minister or a counsellor so he could help others avoid his mistakes.

"I accept that I deserve to be punished for my crime but I beg the court that I not be executed," he said.

"I hope I am given another chance in life."

Both men apologised for previously pleading not guilty, blaming bad advice from their previous legal team. They also apologised for their behaviour at earlier court appearances, conceding they did not show appropriate respect.

Chan and Sukumaran were two of nine Australians convicted over the drug smuggling plot. This final appeal, known as a judicial review, seeks to have their death sentences reduced to 20 years jail.

The appeal rests in large part on evidence that the men have been successfully rehabilitated and are now role models inside prison.

It also argues previous rulings against them erred by finding them guilty of exporting drugs, even though they were caught before exportation actually occurred.

The appeal also argues that earlier decisions were also in error because they contravened international laws, adopted by Indonesia, that reject the use of the death penalty against narcotics criminals.

If the appeal fails they will be left with just one last unlikely chance for survival: clemency from staunch anti-drugs President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono.

Fellow Bali Nine death row inmate Scott Rush also has a judicial review before the courts.

Five other members of the drug smuggling plot - Martin Stephens, Matthew Norman, Michael Czugaj, Si Yi Chen and Tan Duc Than Nguyen - are serving life sentences. Stephens' judicial review is currently being considered by Indonesia's Supreme Court.

The final member of the drug ring, courier Renae Lawrence, is serving a 20-year sentence.

Chan and Sukumaran's appeal will return to court on October 8.

Source: The Sydney Morning Herald, September 21, 2010

Comments

Doctors warn against Tennessee death penalty protocols

Tennessee’s execution protocol is medically unethical and should be revamped before further executions occur, nearly 40 health care professionals said in a letter to Gov. Bill Lee. Like the coalition of faith leaders who asked for a moratorium on executions earlier this month, the physicians, nurses, and other medical professionals who signed the July 28 letter said they were motivated to speak up after the gruesome and botched execution of Tony Carruthers in May. Carruthers spent 90 minutes bleeding and writhing in agony as an attending physician made repeated unsuccessful attempts to insert an IV into the inmate’s chest after being unable to find useable veins in the arms, legs, and feet. Lee granted Carruthers a one-year reprieve after the ordeal.

After Nearly 30 Years and a Supreme Court Reversal: Assessing the Likely Result of Richard Glossip’s Oklahoma Retrial

DPN asked Grok for a legal analysis of Richard Glossip’s upcoming murder retrial and its likely disposition. Most likely outcome of Richard Glossip’s retrial: acquittal or a hung jury leading to dismissal or no further prosecution, rather than a conviction for first-degree murder. A conviction remains possible but is the less probable result given the severely damaged core evidence and the state’s own prior admissions. Death is off the table. Case background

Arizona prosecutors seek death penalty a second time for 2 inmates

County Attorney Brad Miller said Aug. 6 that the nature of the attack and both men's past criminal records meet the strict legal bar required for execution under Arizona law. FLORENCE, Ariz. - Pinal County prosecutors are seeking the death penalty against two inmates accused of violently killing a fellow prisoner behind bars, officials announced Thursday. Pinal County Attorney Brad Miller filed a Notice of Intent to Seek the Death Penalty against Pete Van Winkle and Tracy Hampton in connection with the fatal attack on Kenneth Thompson.

Tennessee | The doctor who helps put prisoners to death

Dr. Mark Fowler assisted in the failed execution of a Tennessee prisoner. Physicians are meant to heal patients—why is he working in the death chamber? Mark Fowler, a physician with 25 years’ experience, stepped beneath the bright lights and approached the middle-aged man lying on a gurney. Around him, people in medical gowns prepared needles and sterile tubing. It had all the appearances of a hospital setting. Fowler had been called in to help establish an IV line through which the 57-year-old man, Tony Carruthers, would be injected with pharmaceutical drugs. The team had struggled to find a vein, so Fowler was summoned to set a central line—an intravenous catheter inserted into the major vein below the collarbone.

Florida | 49 years on death row, killer of Bonita Springs teen learns death date

A Fort Myers man on death row for nearly five decades learned his execution date as Gov. Ron DeSantis signed his order Thursday, July 30. Harold Gene Lucas, then 24, shot and killed his 16-year-old girlfriend, Anthia Jill Piper in Bonita Springs on August 14, 1976. Lucas was 24 when he was charged in Piper's shooting death at her parents' home on Aug. 14, 1976. The execution is set for Sept. 1 in a state that has accelerated its pace under DeSantis the past two years, with a record of 19 executions in 2025. Piper was shot seven times by Lucas, who claimed to be intoxicated.

Iran executes 20-year-old protester as fears grow for other detainees

Iranian authorities executed 20-year-old protester Arvin Kheirkhah at Shahroud prison on Saturday morning, according to information obtained by Iran International, amid concerns that several other detainees could also face execution. Kheirkhah was arrested during the January protests and sentenced to death by a Revolutionary Court on charges including moharebeh , or “waging war against God.” He was transferred to solitary confinement on Wednesday ahead of the execution. His family gathered outside Shahroud prison on Friday night in an attempt to stop the sentence from being carried out. According to information received by Iran International, Kheirkhah told his family in a final conversation: “Don’t let them forget me. We stood up for the liberation of our homeland. Don’t let the path we chose be silenced.”

Florida | Judge refuses to let convicted serial killer speak as she sentences him to death

A Florida judge denied a request from a convicted serial killer to speak in court as she sentenced him to death on Tuesday. A jury convicted Demorris Hunter, 60, of 1st-degree murder and theft in the death of Theresa Ann Green, 38, who was strangled and left in the trunk of her car. “Demorris Andy Hunter, you have not only forfeited your right to dwell among us as a free man, but by your actions and under the law of the State of Florida, you have forfeited your right to live, as well,” Judge Lisa Munyon said as she handed down the sentence Tuesday morning.

Death row inmate sues Tennessee, claiming state denied private confession before execution

A Tennessee death row inmate and his chosen spiritual advisor have filed a federal lawsuit against the Tennessee Department of Correction, alleging state prison policies violate their religious rights by preventing a private confession before execution. The lawsuit, filed in U.S. District Court, does not challenge Tennessee’s authority to carry out executions. Instead, it asks whether condemned inmates have a constitutional and federally protected right to privately practice their faith before the state carries out a death sentence. John Michael Bane has spent decades on Tennessee’s death row after a Shelby County jury convicted him of 1st-degree felony murder in the 1988 robbery and killing of 60-year-old Royce Frazier.

Idaho | How Bryan Kohberger’s Guilty Plea Move Could Be His Death Sentence

If Bryan Kohberger successfully withdraws his guilty plea and goes to trial for the murders of four University of Idaho students, it could lead to him being sentenced to death, experts told Newsweek . Kohberger, 31, filed a handwritten petition on Monday from the Idaho Maximum Security Penitentiary, where he is serving four consecutive life sentences for the murders of Kaylee Goncalves, Ethan Chapin, Xana Kernodle and Madison Mogen in a rental home near the university's campus in Moscow, Idaho, in 2022. Kohberger pleaded guilty to the fatal stabbings just over a year ago, a month before jury selection was set to start.

North Korea | 'I was only 9': North Korean defector recalls childhood memory of public execution

Kim Eun-joo was 9 years old when her teacher stopped their lesson and told the class to follow her outside. The children were marched to a public execution ground in North Korea. “I would cry even when our family dog died,” Kim said in a recent interview with The Korea Times. “But the first time I watched humans killing a human, I had no words for what I was feeling. It was the most brutal scene I have ever seen, in any movie or in real life.” The memory has stayed with her ever since. Now a human rights advocate after defecting from North Korea, Kim recently brought that childhood scene to the 9th World Congress Against the Death Penalty in Paris, where North Korea’s use of public executions and capital punishment was officially placed on the agenda for the first time.

Death Penalty News

Search This Blog