"One is absolutely sickened, not by the crimes that the wicked have committed, but by the punishments that the good have inflicted." - Oscar Wilde

Monday, November 28, 2016

Charleston shooting: Dylann Roof to defend himself

"Judge Richard Gergel said 22-year-old Dylann Roof's wish to be his own lawyer was "unwise", but nevertheless granted his request."
"Judge Richard Gergel said 22-year-old Dylann Roof's wish to be his own
lawyer was "unwise", but nevertheless granted his request."
A white man accused of killing nine black people at a South Carolina church will be allowed to represent himself at trial, a federal judge has said.

US District Judge Richard Gergel said 22-year-old Dylann Roof's wish to be his own lawyer was "unwise", but nevertheless granted his request.

The surprise development came just as jury selection was set to begin.

Last week Mr Roof was deemed competent to stand trial in the shooting of nine Charleston parishioners in June 2015.

Wearing a grey jail-issue jumpsuit, he was sitting on Monday morning at his defence table after his lawyers moved to the side.

Judge Gergel told the court: "I do find defendant has the personal capacity to self-representation."

Addressing Mr Roof, he said: "I continue to believe it is strategically unwise (to represent yourself), but it is a decision you have the right to make."

Mr Roof smiled slightly and replied quietly: "yes, sir."

Beginning on Monday, 516 potential jurors will be questioned individually by the judge; 12 will ultimately be selected to decide his fate.

As the judge began questioning potential jurors - the first 10 of whom were white - Mr Roof did not ask questions or make any objections.

Mr Roof faces 33 federal charges, including a hate crime count.

He has already been found competent in a state court, where he faces nine counts of murder, and prosecutors say they will seek the death penalty.

One juror was struck from the final panel by the judge after expressing reluctance to enforce the death penalty.

"You are playing little bit of God in there. That's what makes me hesitant," the female juror told Judge Gergel.

Federal prosecutors claim the mass shooting on a Bible study class at Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston was racially motivated.

Photos emerged online in the aftermath of Mr Roof holding the Confederate battle flag, sparking a backlash against the emblem, which critics see as a symbol of slavery.

Source: BBC News, November 28, 2016

Judge says Dylann Roof can act as his own attorney in Charleston shooting trial


A white man accused of fatally shooting nine black parishioners at a Charleston, S.C., church last year was allowed to act as his own attorney in his federal death penalty trial Monday.

Dylann Roof's request came against his lawyers' advice, and U.S. District Judge Richard Gergel said he would reluctantly accept the 22-year-old's "unwise" decision.

Death penalty attorney David Bruck then slid over and let Roof take the lead chair. The lawyers can stand by and help Roof if he asks.

The development came the same day jury selection resumed in the case. The selection process was halted Nov. 7 after lawyers for Roof questioned his ability to understand the case against him. Gergel's ruling last week cleared the way for Monday's process to begin anew.

Dylann Roof
Dylann Roof: "an unwise decision"
Roof, 22, is charged with counts including hate crimes and obstruction of religion in connection with the June 17, 2015, attack at Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston. He faces a possible death sentence if convicted.

Beginning Monday, 516 potential jurors were to report to the courthouse to be individually questioned by the judge. When 70 qualified jurors are picked, attorneys can use strikes to dismiss those they don't want, until 12 jurors and six alternates are seated.

The judge delayed the process of narrowing the jury pool when Roof's lawyers suggested that their client either didn't understand the charges against him or couldn't properly help with his defense. The lawyers didn't say what led them to question Roof's fitness for trial.

The decision came after Gergel wrapped up a hastily called two-day hearing to determine if Roof is mentally fit to stand trial, hearing testimony from psychologist James Ballenger and four other unnamed witnesses and reviewed sworn statements from three others.

The judge said he took the rare step of closing the hearing to the public and media because Roof made statements to a psychologist that might not be legal to use at his trial and could taint potential jurors.

On Friday, the judge said he refrained from releasing a transcript of the hearing for the same reason, reversing an earlier pledge to release a redacted transcript. Victims' relatives complained about the secrecy surrounding the proceedings, but Gergel maintains the steps he has taken are to ensure Roof receives a fair trial and that pre-trial exposure doesn't provide grounds for an appeal.

Roof also has already been found competent in state court, where prosecutors plan a second death penalty trial on nine counts of murder.

According to police, Roof sat through nearly an hour of prayer and Bible study at the church with its pastor and 11 others before pulling a gun from his fanny pack and firing dozens of shots.

Roof shouted racial insults at the six women and three men he is charged with killing and the three people left alive, authorities said. Roof said he left the three unharmed so they could tell the world the shootings were because he hated black people, according to authorities.

Source: L.A. Times, The Associated Press, November 28, 2016

⚑ | Report an error, an omission; suggest a story or a new angle to an existing story; send a submission; recommend a resource; contact the webmaster, contact us: deathpenaltynews@gmail.com.


Opposed to Capital Punishment? Help us keep this blog up and running! DONATE!