Sotomayor expresses concerns about Florida’s lethal injection protocol

Justice Sonia Sotomayor expressed concerns about Florida’s lethal injection procedure on Tuesday, urging more transparency as the Supreme Court denied a man’s emergency bid to avoid execution later in the day.

The seniormost liberal justice voted with her colleagues to allow Melvin Trotter’s execution to move forward over the 1986 murder of a grocery store owner, saying Trotter hadn’t shown enough evidence that the state will mangle the procedure.

“Even so, the record to date is troubling,” Sotomayor wrote.

Her four-page solo opinion raises alarm that Florida’s lethal injection protocol has possible flaws, but state courts have prevented defendants from obtaining records to prove it.RELATED | Florida executes Melvin Trotter

Those courts have denied defendants’ records requests by ruling they don’t have enough information to raise a claim under the Eighth Amendment, which protects against cruel and unusual punishment. But Sotomayor noted the very reason they are seeking the records is to gather that information.

“In doing so, the Florida Supreme Court appears to be placing prisoners in a Catch-22,” she wrote.

Sotomayor called on Florida and its courts to provide more transparency and ensure the prevention of “any infliction of needless suffering on those being executed.”

The Hill has reached out to Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier’s (R) office for comment.

Trotter, 65, [was] be executed Tuesday evening over the 1986 murder of Virgie Langford during a robbery of her grocery store. Trotter argued that past death row inmates’ lethal injections in Florida have been administered improperly, and his may be mangled, too.

“But those claims derive from heavily redacted records that do not establish that any protocol deviation occurred,” the state pushed back in court filings. “The materials do not identify executed inmates, confirm that the listed drugs were administered, or demonstrate that any irregularities affected executions.”

Under Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R), the state last year carried out a record 19 executions.

Many inmates file emergency bids with the Supreme Court ahead of their executions, but the justices rarely step in to stop them from proceeding.

Tuesday’s decision marks the fourth time this calendar year the justices have ruled on a death row inmate’s emergency appeal, according to The Hill’s review of the court’s docket. All have been denied.

Source: The Hill, Zach Svhonfelf, February 24, 2026

"One is absolutely sickened, not by the crimes that the wicked have committed,
but by the punishments that the good have inflicted."

— Oscar Wilde

Death Penalty News For a World without the Death Penalty