USA | The Dreadful Failure of Lethal Injection

Editor’s Note: This column is the product of a research collaboration with five Amherst College students, Mattea Denny, Nicolas Graber-Mitchell, Greene Ko, Rose Mroczka, and Lauren Pelosi. America’s death penalty continues to fall out of favor, a well-known fact. When the year started, eight executions were scheduled for February and March in five different states. But all of them are now on hold, and two of the three executions that were set for April already have been halted. While advocacy for the end of the death penalty has played some role, it is the decomposition of the lethal injection paradigm that has truly driven down execution numbers. We have now seen a decade of chaos and experimentation as death penalty jurisdictions tried to find reliable sources of drugs to carry out executions. States rolled out new drugs, but things did not go smoothly. The number of mishaps associated with lethal injection increased substantially. From 2010-2020, an already problematic method of ex

Lawyers for Singapore man facing death penalty in Vietnam to seek stay of execution

The human rights lawyer said that the Ministry of Foreign Affairs must provide a breakdown on S'poreans being held in prison in foreign countries

The Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA) must provide on its website a breakdown of Singaporeans being held in prison in foreign countries, said human rights lawyer M Ravi.

In an interview with The Independent Singapore published on 24 Feb, Mr Ravi opined that there should be “transparency of information”, given the precarity of capital punishment.

Death penalty advocates and death penalty lawyers like himself, as well as NGOs, were not made aware of information on two Singaporeans facing capital punishment in China and Vietnam respectively, according to Mr Ravi.

“At least, we are taking steps to safeguard against any unlawful execution or indiscriminate execution as such,” he added.

Mr Ravi is representing Singaporean Cher Wei Hon, who is currently facing the death penalty for drug trafficking in Vietnam.

Similar to the case of Siti Aslinda Binte Junaidi, another Singaporean represented by Mr Ravi and facing the death penalty in China for the same offence, Mr Ravi said that his team “had a lot of difficulty in getting a lawyer” due to hefty legal fees.

In Dec last year, Mr Ravi said that Mr Cher’s family had reached out to him after reports on Ms Aslinda surfaced.

He decided to take on Mr Cher’s case on a pro bono basis, as Mr Cher has three young children who are being looked after by his ailing mother.

Finding a “very competent lawyer at this stage” where the death penalty has been handed down by the courts also proved to be a challenge in Mr Cher’s case, Mr Ravi told The Independent on 24 Feb.

“To review this case, you need to have a lot of specialised skills, and fortunately I’m able to reach out to my network and I’m able to get one recommendation,” said Mr Ravi, adding that he is currently coordinating with the lawyer, referred to as Mr Phan.

The team of lawyers in Vietnam who are jointly working with him, said Mr Ravi, are “very kind and they have accepted what we call ‘low bono’, as in lower amount of fees, which I think is highly reasonable”.

“But even then, the families (are) facing difficulty (in raising the funds), but I hope they can raise that amount. But otherwise, as I said in terms of urgency, it has emerged that Cher needs immediate attention,” said Mr Ravi.

Lawyers seeking to apply for Cher Wei Hon’s stay of execution 

Noting that Mr Cher has submitted a clemency petition to the Vietnamese President, Mr Ravi said that “we have to ascertain from (our) Vietnamese counterparts very clearly as to whether is it safe for us to just depend on the stay of execution by the president”.

The final petition was already submitted to the president after the appeal was concluded, he added.

Mr Ravi also said that his team of lawyers are seeking to apply for a stay of execution for Mr Cher, in view of the prospect of the latter’s case being reviewed again by the court.

“So that is not been done yet, but we are looking into it,” he said.

Mr Cher’s case seems to be more urgent than Ms Aslinda’s case, according to Mr Ravi, as the petition has been sent to the president.

While Ms Aslinda may be subject to death by shooting in China, Mr Ravi noted that in Vietnam, the death penalty is carried out through lethal injections.

“And now, once it is turned down, the lethal injection will be administered by way of execution.

“We don’t want that. We would like to have his case properly reviewed,” said Mr Ravi, stressing that there are many “evidential issues” in both Mr Cher and Ms Aslinda’s cases that have not been dealt with thoroughly in investigations and in the courts.

Drug weight threshold for death penalty “arbitrary”: M Ravi

Mothership previously reported that Mr Cher had said that he transported the drugs to pay off his debt.

Mr Cher reportedly became acquainted with a woman named Quynh at a karaoke parlour in Vietnam, from whom he borrowed VND200 million (S$11,832).

To compensate for his debt, Ms Quynh originally made Mr Cher transport iPhones and iPads from Cambodia to Vietnam.

However, she later tasked him to move drugs across the border.

Commenting on the threshold of drug weights that would make an individual subject to the death penalty, Mr Ravi said that the starting point for the death penalty for trafficking drugs such as methamphetamine is 2.5 kilograms and above.

“For heroin, it’s 600 grams. So what if it’s 599? And what if it’s 2.49? Just that 0.0 to 0.1 (kilograms’ difference). How can that make a difference to a person’s life?” He questioned.

“It is so arbitrary … The death penalty itself has not been a solution. We all know that that penalty has only opened all wounds. As I said, it is disproportionately applied against the poor,” Mr Ravi stressed.

Two-thirds of the countries globally, he added, has abolished the death penalty.

“So I don’t see that (as) a solution,” said Mr Ravi.

MFA on 13 Aug last year said that it is aware of the case and in contact with Mr Cher’s family.

“Our Consulate-General in Ho Chi Minh City is rendering consular assistance to Mr Cher,” MFA was reported by Mothership as saying.

Source: theonlinecitizen.com, Staff, March 4, 2021

đŸš© | Report an error, an omission, a typo; suggest a story or a new angle to an existing story; submit a piece, a comment; recommend a resource; contact the webmaster, contact us: deathpenaltynews@gmail.com.

Opposed to Capital Punishment? Help us keep this blog up and running! DONATE!

"One is absolutely sickened, not by the crimes that the wicked have committed,
but by the punishments that the good have inflicted." -- Oscar Wilde

Most Viewed (Last 30 Days)

Saudi Arabia | Execution caught on video

30-year-old Chinese inmate bids farewell to daughter, wife and mother before execution

USA | Are Life Sentences a Merciful Alternative to the Death Penalty?

Philippines: A moral, ethical issue for our people

Texas | Woman Who Witnessed Around 300 Executions Reveals The Inmates' Last Words That Have Stayed With Her

Iran | Woman Hanged for Killing Abusive Husband; Daughter Carried Out the Execution

USA | The Dreadful Failure of Lethal Injection

Indiana | Serial killer Joseph Duncan dies on death row

Indonesia | Lindsay Sandiford, now 64, has spent over 8 years on Bali's death row

North Korea | 4 Publicly Executed In Pyongyang On Charges Of Distributing ‘Illegal Video Materials’