Texas Should Not Have Executed Robert Pruett

Update: Robert Pruett was executed by lethal injection on Thursday.
Robert Pruett is scheduled to be executed by the State of Texas Thursday. He has never had a chance to live outside a prison as an adult. Taking his life is a senseless wrong that shows how badly the justice system fails juveniles.
Mr. Pruett was 15 years old when he last saw the outside world, after being arrested as an accomplice to a murder committed by his own father. Now 38, having been convicted of a murder while incarcerated, he will be put to death. At a time when the Supreme Court has begun to recognize excessive punishments for juveniles as unjust, Mr. Pruett’s case shows how young lives can be destroyed by a justice system that refuses to give second chances.
Mr. Pruett’s father, Sam Pruett, spent much of Mr. Pruett’s early childhood in prison. Mr. Pruett and his three siblings were raised in various trailer parks by his mother, who he has said used drugs heavily and often struggled to feed the children. Wh…

Alabama executes Leroy White

Leroy White
(Reuters) - Alabama executed by lethal injection a death row inmate on Thursday who had been convicted of murdering his wife by shooting her at point blank range with a shotgun.

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas briefly raised the hopes of Leroy White, 52, when he granted a temporary stay of execution shortly before White was due to die.

But hours later the Court denied the request for a stay and White died at 9.10 p.m. central time at Holman Correctional Facility in Atmore, according to Brian Corbett, spokesman for Alabama department of corrections.

White murdered his estranged wife Ruby White in 1988 in a domestic dispute.

He shot her once and when she did not die immediately, he reloaded, picked up the couple's 17-month-old daughter, and fired again. He also shot his sister-in-law Stella Lanier four times, court documents said.

No members of the victim's family witnessed the execution, although two friends of White attended. White's last meal was a cheeseburger from the vending machine plus a V8 juice, pork skins and a Yahoo drink, Corbett said.

White's attorneys said their client had deserved more time for appeal because his previous lawyers did not notify him that a U.S. district court had turned down an appeal, which caused him to miss a crucial filing deadline.

White was executed "because he was too poor to get the legal assistance he needed at trial and thereafter for his post-conviction appeals," said his lawyer Bryan Stephenson.

"This is a case where the trial prosecutors did not believe the death penalty was appropriate, the jury did not believe the death penalty was appropriate, and the victim's family does not believe the death penalty is appropriate," said Stephenson.

Court documents showed the trial jury recommended life without parole. Stephenson said Lanier had also pleaded with Alabama governor Bob Riley for clemency.

With 30 executions carried out in 2010, Alabama ranked third last year in number of executions, according to the Death Penalty Information Center. Texas far exceeded all other states with 269 executions in 2010, with Oklahoma second with 73.

White becomes the 1st condemned inmate to be put to death this year in Alabama and the 50th overall since the state resumed capital punishment in 1983.

White becomes the 3rd condemned inmate to be put to death this year in the USA and the 1237th overall since the nation resumed executions on January 17, 1977.

Source: Reuters, Rick Halperin, January 14, 2011

Leroy White's last few hours continued odd journey to his execution

Leroy White's last visitor left at 4:30 p.m. Thursday, an hour and a half before he was scheduled to be executed.

With no visitors allowed, White couldn't ask his lawyer what was happening. But shortly before the 6 p.m. execution, Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas issued a stay to consider a final motion in the former Huntsville resident and convicted murderer's case.

White sat in a cell near the gurney, waiting to learn his fate.

Nearly 3 hours later, shortly before 9 p.m., White was executed for the shotgun slaying of his estranged wife, Ruby White, at her Evans Drive home on Oct. 17, 1988.

The wait marked one final odd turn in White's case, which featured the victim's family asking that his life be spared, and one of White's own lawyers admitting he allowed White to miss a critical deadline to appeal.

That request was rejected by Gov. Bob Riley.

The jury at his trial recommended that he be given a life sentence for shooting his estranged wife twice with a shotgun, the 2nd time while he was holding the couple's 17-month-old daughter. But the judge in the case didn't accept the jury's recommendation and instead gave him the death penalty. The couple's daughter also asked Riley to spare White.

White's lawyer, Brian Stevenson, director of the Montgomery-based Equal Justice Initiative, which opposes capital punishment, took up White's case last summer, after White was notified Alabama had asked the state Supreme Court to set an execution date.

White was surprised to learn an execution date was approaching, and assumed he was still in the appeals process, Stevenson said.

Over the past week Stevenson petitioned both the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals and the U.S. Supreme Court, asking that the execution be delayed because White's appeals process had been short-circuited by an inexperienced lawyer who withdrew without telling White.

That withdrawal resulted in White missing a crucial appeal deadline and started the clock for the scheduling of his execution.

Both courts rejected the missed deadline argument, despite an affidavit by former attorney G. James Benoit of Maryland, who admitted withdrawing for unrelated work reasons and failing to tell White about it.

Benoit, who took over White's case after another member of his law firm was suspended from practicing law, said he doesn't believe he communicated with White during the time an appeal could be filed. He said he was unaware of rules that required him to file an appeal.

"At all times I represented Mr. White pro bono," Benoit wrote. "I formerly practiced transactional tax and corporate law and no longer practice law. I have never tried a case and have never been in a courtroom in my career."

Benoit was White's lawyer in June 2009 when the U.S. District Court rejected his claims of ineffective assistance of counsel during his trial. White was offered a deal to plea to capital murder and spend life in prison, but he rejected it. Stevenson argued he was badly advised by his trial attorney.

Alabama Assistant Attorney General Clayton Crenshaw, who heads Alabama's Capital Litigation Division, said White had numerous reviews of his case and each of his arguments over the roughly 21-year appeals process was heard by the courts.

Crenshaw said the case file has filled 10 boxes.

He said the missed deadline is an issue that White's lawyers raised in the final days of his life, but they didn't have a persuasive argument on the key issue: given more time to appeal, could he win the appeal on the merits of his case?

Stevenson said about half of the roughly 200 prisoners on Alabama's death row were represented by a lawyer who is not allowed to spend more than $1,000 on out-of-court time working on the case, unless given permission by the trial court under Alabama indigent defense rules. He said that inequity leads to problems with the quality of assistance defendants are getting.

"The death penalty is not just about do people deserve to die for the crimes they are accused of, the death penalty is also about do we deserve to kill," Stevenson said. "If we don't provide fair trials, fair review procedures, when we have executions that are unnecessarily cruel and distressing, or if we have a death penalty that is arbitrary or political or discriminatory, then we are all implicated."

Source: The Hunstville Times, January 15, 2011


Most Viewed (Last 7 Days)

Texas Should Not Have Executed Robert Pruett

Texas executes Robert Pruett

Texas: Houston Man Condemned in Family Murder Plot Loses High Court Appeal

Texas: Montgomery County DA asks governor to stay Anthony Shore's execution

Iran: Young man has hand judicially amputated over jewelry theft

Why Indonesia Delays Execution of Death Row Convicts

Pakistan's angel of death

Hours before execution, Tourniquet Killer granted 90-day stay at DA's request

Execution stayed for Alabama man convicted of killing cop

8 years since last Thai execution, future of death penalty uncertain